Department of Biomedical Sciences and Imaging, Biomedical Imaging Research Institute (BIRI), Cedars-Sinai Medical Center, Los Angeles, CA, USA.
Department of Medicine, University of California at Los Angeles, Los Angeles, CA, USA.
Brain Behav. 2020 Dec;10(12):e01846. doi: 10.1002/brb3.1846. Epub 2020 Sep 17.
Defining reliable brain markers for the prediction of abnormal behavioral outcomes remains an urgent but extremely challenging task in neuroscience research. This is particularly important for infant studies given the most dramatic brain and behavioral growth during infancy.
In this study, we proposed a novel prediction scheme through abstracting individual newborn's whole-brain functional connectivity pattern to three outlier measures (Triple O) and tested the hypothesis that neonates identified as "brain outliers" based on Triple O were more likely to develop as IQ outliers at 4 years of age. Without need for training with behavioral data, Triple O represents a novel proof-of-concept approach to predict later IQ outcomes based on neonatal brain data.
Triple O correctly identified 42.1% true IQ outliers among a mixed cohort of 175 newborns with different term, twin, and maternal disorder statuses. Triple O also reached a high level of specificity (96.2%) and overall accuracy (90.3%). Further incorporating a demographic information indicator, the enhanced Triple O+ could further differentiate between high and low 4YR IQ outliers. Validation tests against seven independent reference samples revealed highly consistent results and a minimum sample size of ~50 for robust performance.
Considering that postnatal brain growth and various environmental factors likely also contribute to 4YR IQ, the fact that Triple O, based purely on neonatal functional connectivity data, could identify >40% of 4YR IQ outliers is striking. Together with the very high level of specificity, each outlier predicted by Triple O represents a meaningful risk but future efforts are needed to explore ways to identify the rest of outliers. Overall, with no need for training, a high level of robustness, and a minimal requirement on sample size, the proposed Triple O approach demonstrates great potential to predict later outlying IQ performances using neonatal functional connectivity data.
在神经科学研究中,定义可靠的大脑标志物来预测异常行为结果仍然是一个紧迫但极具挑战性的任务。对于婴儿研究来说,这一点尤为重要,因为婴儿期大脑和行为的发育最为迅速。
在这项研究中,我们提出了一种新的预测方案,通过抽象个体新生儿的全脑功能连接模式来得到三个异常值指标(Triple O),并测试了基于 Triple O 识别的“大脑异常”新生儿在 4 岁时更有可能成为 IQ 异常的假设。无需使用行为数据进行训练,Triple O 代表了一种基于新生儿脑数据预测后续 IQ 结果的新颖的概念验证方法。
Triple O 在一个包含不同足月、双胞胎和产妇疾病状态的 175 名新生儿的混合队列中,正确识别出 42.1%的真正 IQ 异常者。Triple O 还具有高特异性(96.2%)和整体准确性(90.3%)。进一步纳入一个人口统计学信息指标,增强的 Triple O+可以进一步区分高和低 4YR IQ 异常者。对七个独立参考样本的验证测试显示出高度一致的结果,并且稳健性能的最小样本量约为 50。
考虑到产后大脑生长和各种环境因素也可能对 4YR IQ 有贡献,基于纯粹的新生儿功能连接数据,Triple O 可以识别出>40%的 4YR IQ 异常者,这一事实令人瞩目。加上非常高的特异性,Triple O 预测的每个异常者都代表了一个有意义的风险,但未来还需要努力探索识别其余异常者的方法。总体而言,Triple O 方法无需训练、具有高稳健性和最小的样本量要求,展示了使用新生儿功能连接数据预测后续异常 IQ 表现的巨大潜力。