Denton Carolyn A, Tamm Leanne, Schatschneider Christopher, Epstein Jeffery N
Department of Pediatrics, McGovern Medical School, University of Texas Health Science Center Houston.
Department of Pediatrics, University of Cincinnati College of Medicine & Cincinnati Children's Hospital Medical Center.
Sci Stud Read. 2020;24(1):72-89. doi: 10.1080/10888438.2019.1640704. Epub 2019 Jul 19.
Many students with reading difficulties and disabilities (RD) also have Attention Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD). This randomized clinical trial compared the effects of ADHD treatment alone (medication, parent training), intensive reading intervention alone, and their combination on the reading fluency and comprehension of students with both disorders. Students with ADHD and RD were randomly assigned to receive (a) Reading Intervention only (n=74), (b) ADHD Treatment only (n=78), or (c) simultaneous Combined ADHD and RD Treatment (n=70). For phonemic decoding fluency, the Reading Intervention group and the Combined Treatment group both had significantly better outcomes than the ADHD Treatment group, but did not differ from one another. For passage comprehension, the ADHD Treatment group had significantly better outcomes than the Reading Intervention group, while the other groups did not differ from one another. ADHD treatment may support passage comprehension in this population, while fluent decoding is best supported through intensive reading intervention.
许多有阅读困难和阅读障碍(RD)的学生也患有注意力缺陷多动障碍(ADHD)。这项随机临床试验比较了单独的ADHD治疗(药物治疗、家长培训)、单独的强化阅读干预以及两者结合对患有这两种障碍的学生的阅读流畅性和阅读理解能力的影响。患有ADHD和RD的学生被随机分配接受(a)仅阅读干预(n = 74),(b)仅ADHD治疗(n = 78),或(c)同时进行的ADHD和RD联合治疗(n = 70)。在音素解码流畅性方面,阅读干预组和联合治疗组的结果均显著优于ADHD治疗组,但两组之间没有差异。在篇章理解方面,ADHD治疗组的结果显著优于阅读干预组,而其他组之间没有差异。ADHD治疗可能有助于该人群的篇章理解,而通过强化阅读干预能最好地促进流畅解码。