Savioli Gabriele, Ceresa Iride Francesca, Maggioni Paolo, Lava Massimiliano, Ricevuti Giovanni, Manzoni Federica, Oddone Enrico, Bressan Maria Antonietta
Emergency Department, Irccs Policlinico San Matteo, 27100 Pavia, Italy.
PhD School in Experimental Medicine, Department of Clinical-Surgical, Diagnostic and Pediatric Sciences, University of Pavia, 27100 Pavia, Italy.
Medicines (Basel). 2020 Sep 24;7(10):60. doi: 10.3390/medicines7100060.
Adherence to guidelines by physicians of an emergency department (ED) depends on many factors: guideline and environmental factors; patient and practitioner characteristics; the social-political context. We focused on the impact of the environmental influence and of the patients' characteristics on adherence to the guidelines. It is our intention to demonstrate how environmental factors such as ED organization more affect adherence to guidelines than the patient's clinical presentation, even in a clinically insidious disease such as pulmonary embolism (PE). A single-center observational study was carried out on all patients who were seen at our Department of Emergency and Acceptance from 1 January to 31 December 2017 for PE. For the assessment of adherence to guidelines, we used the European guidelines 2014 and analyzed adherence to the correct use of clinical decision rule (CDR as Wells, Geneva, and YEARS); the correct initiation of heparin therapy; and the management of patients at high risk for short-term mortality. The primary endpoint of our study was to determine whether adherence to the guidelines as a whole depends on patients' management in a holding area. The secondary objective was to determine whether adherence to the guidelines depended on patient characteristics such as the presence of typical symptoms or severe clinical features (massive pulmonary embolism; organ damage). There were significant differences between patients who passed through OBI and those who did not, in terms of both administration of heparin therapy alone ( = 0.007) and the composite endpoints of heparin therapy initiation and observation/monitoring ( = 0.004), as indicated by the guidelines. For the subgroups of patients with massive PE, organ damage, and typical symptoms, there was no greater adherence to the decision making, administration of heparin therapy alone, and the endpoints of heparin therapy initiation and guideline-based observation/monitoring. Patients managed in an ED holding area were managed more in accordance with the guidelines than those who were managed only in the visiting ED rooms and directly hospitalized from there.
指南和环境因素、患者及从业者特征、社会政治背景。我们重点关注环境影响和患者特征对指南遵循情况的影响。我们旨在证明,即使在诸如肺栓塞(PE)这种临床隐匿性疾病中,急诊科组织等环境因素对指南遵循情况的影响如何比患者的临床表现更大。对2017年1月1日至12月31日期间在我们急诊与接纳科就诊的所有PE患者进行了一项单中心观察性研究。为评估对指南的遵循情况,我们采用了2014年欧洲指南,并分析了对临床决策规则(如Wells、Geneva和YEARS等临床决策规则)正确使用的遵循情况;肝素治疗的正确启动;以及对短期死亡高风险患者的管理。我们研究的主要终点是确定对指南的整体遵循是否取决于在等候区对患者的管理。次要目标是确定对指南的遵循是否取决于患者特征,如是否存在典型症状或严重临床特征(大面积肺栓塞;器官损害)。如指南所示,在仅使用肝素治疗方面(P = 0.007)以及肝素治疗启动和观察/监测的综合终点方面(P = 0.004),经过OBI的患者与未经过OBI的患者之间存在显著差异。对于大面积PE、器官损害和有典型症状的患者亚组,在决策制定、仅使用肝素治疗以及肝素治疗启动和基于指南的观察/监测终点方面,并没有更高的遵循率。在急诊科等候区接受管理的患者比那些仅在急诊就诊室接受管理并直接从那里住院的患者更符合指南要求。