Department of Communication Sciences and Disorders, University of South Carolina, Columbia.
Lang Speech Hear Serv Sch. 2021 Jan 19;52(1):304-316. doi: 10.1044/2020_LSHSS-20-00041. Epub 2020 Sep 30.
Purpose The purpose of this study was to determine if group differences exist in spelling accuracy or spelling errors between kindergarten children with hearing loss and children with normal hearing loss. Method Participants included 23 kindergarten children with hearing loss and 21 children with normal hearing. All children used spoken English as their primary language, and the children with hearing loss used amplification. Participants completed three single-word spelling assessments, a language assessment, and an oral reading assessment. Spelling was scored holistically and with two linguistic-based scoring systems. Results Children with hearing loss did not differ significantly from children with normal hearing in spelling accuracy or linguistic-based spelling error analyses. Conclusions The current study provides evidence that children with hearing loss in kindergarten do not differ significantly in their spelling errors compared to children with normal hearing, aside from a lower proportion of mental graphemic representation errors. With these data, in combination with previous research conducted, speech-language pathologists can further individualize treatment to focus on these specific error patterns. Additionally, this focus of treatment can help better prepare children with hearing loss for spelling and writing tasks in later grades. Future research should be conducted to determine when in elementary school the differences in spelling errors are initially seen.
目的 本研究旨在确定听力损失的幼儿园儿童和听力正常的儿童在拼写准确性或拼写错误方面是否存在群体差异。
方法 参与者包括 23 名听力损失的幼儿园儿童和 21 名听力正常的儿童。所有儿童均以英语口语作为主要语言,听力损失儿童使用助听设备。参与者完成了三项单字拼写评估、一项语言评估和一项朗读评估。拼写成绩采用整体评分和两种基于语言的评分系统进行评分。
结果 听力损失儿童在拼写准确性或基于语言的拼写错误分析方面与听力正常儿童无显著差异。
结论 本研究提供的证据表明,幼儿园听力损失儿童的拼写错误与听力正常儿童相比没有显著差异,除了心理字形表象错误的比例较低。有了这些数据,结合之前进行的研究,言语语言病理学家可以进一步针对这些特定的错误模式进行个性化治疗。此外,这种治疗重点可以帮助听力损失儿童更好地为以后年级的拼写和写作任务做好准备。应进行未来的研究以确定在小学何时首次出现拼写错误的差异。