Petitprez K, Guillaume S, Mattuizzi A, Arnal M, Artzner F, Bernard C, Bonnin M, Bouvet L, Caron F-M, Chevalier I, Daussy-Urvoy C, Ducloy-Bouthorsc A-S, Garnier J-M, Keita-Meyer H, Lavillonnière J, Lejeune-Sadaa V, Leray C, Morandeau A, Morau E, Nadjafizade M, Pizzagalli F, Schantz C, Schmitz T, Shojai R, Hédon B, Sentilhes L
Service des bonnes pratiques professionnelles, Haute Autorité de santé, 93218 Saint-Denis, France.
Service de gynécologie-obstétrique, hôpital Necker-Enfants-Malades, Assistance publique des Hôpitaux de Paris, 75015 Paris, France.
Gynecol Obstet Fertil Senol. 2020 Dec;48(12):873-882. doi: 10.1016/j.gofs.2020.09.013. Epub 2020 Oct 1.
The objective of these guidelines is to define for women at low obstetric risk modalities that respect the physiology of delivery and guarantee the quality and safety of maternal and newborn care.
These guidelines were made by a consensus of experts based on an analysis of the scientific literature and the French and international recommendations available on the subject.
It is recommended to conduct a complete initial examination of the woman in labor at admission (consensus agreement). The labor will be monitored using a partogram that is a useful traceability tool (consensus agreement). A transvaginal examination may be offered every two to four hours during the first stage of labor and every hour during the second stage of labor or before if the patient requests it, or in case of a warning sign. It is recommended that if anesthesia is required, epidural or spinal anesthesia should be used to prevent bronchial inhalation (grade A). The consumption of clear fluids is permitted throughout labor in patients with a low risk of general anesthesia (grade B). It is recommended to carry out a "low dose" epidural analgesia that respects the experience of delivery (grade A). It is recommended to maintain the epidural analgesia through a woman's self-administration pump (grade A). It is recommended to give the woman the choice of continuous (by cardiotocography) or discontinuous (by cardiotocography or intermittent auscultation) monitoring if the conditions of maternity organization and the permanent availability of staff allow it and, after having informed the woman of the benefits and risks of each technique (consensus agreement). In the active phase of the first stage of labor, the dilation rate is considered abnormal if it is less than 1cm/4h between 5 and 7cm or less than 1cm/2h above 7cm (level of Evidence 2). It is then recommended to propose an amniotomy if the membranes are intact or an oxytocin administration if the membranes are already ruptured, and the uterine contractions considered insufficient (consensus agreement). It is recommended not to start expulsive efforts as soon as complete dilation is identified, but to let the presentation of the fetus drop (grade A). It is recommended to inform the gynecologist-obstetrician in case of nonprogression of the fetus after two hours of complete dilation with sufficient uterine dynamics (consensus agreement). It is recommended not to use abdominal expression (grade B). It is recommended to carry out preventive administration of oxytocin at 5 or 10 IU to prevent PPH after vaginal delivery (grade A). In the case of placental retention, it is recommended to perform a manual removal of the placenta (grade A). In the absence of bleeding, it should be performed 30minutes but not more than 60minutes after delivery (consensus agreement). It is recommended to assess at birth the breathing or screaming, and tone of the newborn to quickly determine if resuscitation is required (consensus agreement). If the parameters are satisfactory (breathing present, screaming frankly, and normal tonicity), it is recommended to propose to the mother that she immediately place the newborn skin-to-skin with her mother if she wishes, with a monitoring protocol (grade B). Delayed cord clamping is recommended beyond the first 30seconds in neonates, not requiring resuscitation (grade C). It is recommended that the first oral dose (2mg) of vitamin K (consensus agreement) be given systematically within two hours of birth.
These guidelines allow women at low obstetric risk to benefit from a better quality of care and optimal safety conditions while respecting the physiology of delivery.
本指南的目的是为低产科风险的女性确定尊重分娩生理过程并确保孕产妇和新生儿护理质量与安全的方式。
这些指南是专家们在分析科学文献以及该主题的法国和国际建议的基础上达成共识制定的。
建议在产妇入院时进行全面的初始检查(达成共识)。使用产程图监测产程,产程图是一种有用的可追溯工具(达成共识)。在第一产程期间,每2至4小时可进行一次阴道检查,在第二产程期间每小时进行一次阴道检查,或者如果患者要求,或出现警示信号时可提前进行。建议如果需要麻醉,应使用硬膜外或脊髓麻醉以防止支气管吸入(A级)。对于全身麻醉风险低的患者,整个产程允许饮用清亮液体(B级)。建议实施尊重分娩体验的“低剂量”硬膜外镇痛(A级)。建议通过产妇自控泵维持硬膜外镇痛(A级)。如果产科机构条件和工作人员随时可用,建议在告知产妇每种技术的益处和风险后,让产妇选择连续(通过胎心监护)或间断(通过胎心监护或间歇性听诊)监测(达成共识)。在第一产程的活跃期,如果宫颈扩张速度在5至7厘米之间小于1厘米/4小时或在7厘米以上小于1厘米/2小时,则认为扩张速度异常(证据级别2)。如果胎膜完整,建议行人工破膜;如果胎膜已破且子宫收缩被认为不足,则建议使用缩宫素(达成共识)。建议在宫颈完全扩张后不要立即开始用力,而是让胎儿先入盆(A级)。建议在宫颈完全扩张且子宫动力充足两小时后胎儿仍无进展时通知妇产科医生(达成共识)。建议不要使用腹部按压(B级)。建议在阴道分娩后预防性给予5或10国际单位的缩宫素以预防产后出血(A级)。如果胎盘滞留,建议行人工剥离胎盘(A级)。在无出血的情况下,应在分娩后30分钟但不超过60分钟进行(达成共识)。建议在出生时评估新生儿的呼吸或哭声以及肌张力,以快速确定是否需要复苏(达成共识)。如果参数令人满意(有呼吸、哭声响亮且肌张力正常),建议如果母亲愿意,可立即让新生儿与母亲进行皮肤接触,并遵循监测方案(B级)。对于不需要复苏的新生儿,建议延迟脐带结扎超过30秒(C级)。建议在出生后两小时内系统地给予第一剂口服维生素K(2毫克)(达成共识)。
这些指南使低产科风险的女性在尊重分娩生理过程的同时,能够受益于更高质量的护理和最佳安全条件。