Perelman School of Medicine, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA, USA.
Perelman School of Medicine, Standardized Patient Program, University of Pennsylvania, PA, USA.
J Genet Couns. 2021 Apr;30(2):493-502. doi: 10.1002/jgc4.1335. Epub 2020 Oct 6.
Standardized patients (SPs) are laypersons trained to portray patients, family members, and others in a consistent, measurable manner to teach and assess healthcare students, and to provide practice for emotionally and medically challenging cases. SP methodology has been studied with practicing genetic counselors; however, there is minimal empirical evidence characterizing its use in genetic counseling (GC) education. The Accreditation Council for Genetic Counseling (ACGC) Standards of Accreditation for Graduate Programs in Genetic Counseling include SP sessions as one way to achieve up to 20% of the 50 participatory cases required for graduation. The purpose of the current project was to determine the scope, frequency, and timing of SP methodology in ACGC-accredited programs to establish baseline usage, which happened prior to the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic. A 40-item investigator-created survey was developed to document the scope and frequency of SP use among programs. The survey was distributed through the Association of Genetic Counseling Program Directors' (AGCPD) listserv to 43 accredited and 6 programs under development. Surveys were analyzed from 25 accredited programs (response rate = 58%). Seventeen of these programs report inclusion of SP methodology in the curricula (68%), of which 13 report working with an established SP program. SPs are used predominantly for role-plays (70.6%), individualized instruction and remediation (29.4%), and for other reasons such as lecture demonstration, final examinations, practicing skills, and assessing students' goals. Sixteen of the participating programs use SPs to give GC students experience disclosing positive test results. Other details vary among the GC programs including the use of trained SPs, volunteer or paid SPs, actors with and without SP training, or GC students acting as patients. This study demonstrates that GC program SP experiences differ, but are largely viewed as valuable by the programs. Many GC programs report using SP encounters to create multiple opportunities for students to practice and refine clinical skills similar to SPs in medical school.
标准化患者(SP)是经过培训的非专业人员,他们以一致、可衡量的方式扮演患者、家庭成员和其他角色,以教授和评估医疗保健学生,并为情感和医学上具有挑战性的病例提供实践机会。SP 方法已在执业遗传咨询师中进行了研究;然而,在遗传咨询(GC)教育中使用其的经验证据很少。遗传咨询师认证委员会(ACGC)的遗传咨询研究生课程认证标准包括 SP 课程,作为达到毕业要求的 50 个参与病例中 20%的一种方式。当前项目的目的是确定在 ACGC 认证计划中 SP 方法的范围、频率和时间,以建立基线使用情况,这是在 SARS-CoV-2 大流行之前进行的。制定了一份由调查员创建的 40 项调查,以记录计划中 SP 使用的范围和频率。该调查通过遗传咨询项目主任协会(AGCPD)的名单分发给 43 个认证和 6 个正在开发的项目。从 25 个认证项目中分析了调查(响应率为 58%)。其中 17 个项目报告在课程中纳入了 SP 方法(68%),其中 13 个报告与已建立的 SP 计划合作。SP 主要用于角色扮演(70.6%)、个性化指导和补救(29.4%),以及其他原因,如讲座演示、期末考试、练习技能和评估学生的目标。参与的 16 个项目使用 SP 让 GC 学生体验阳性测试结果的披露。GC 项目之间的其他细节也有所不同,包括使用经过培训的 SP、志愿者或付费 SP、有和没有 SP 培训的演员,或 GC 学生扮演患者。这项研究表明,GC 项目的 SP 体验不同,但总体上被项目视为有价值。许多 GC 项目报告说,他们使用 SP 接触来为学生创造多次机会,以练习和完善临床技能,类似于医学院的 SP。