IFSTTAR, Laboratoire de Psychologie des Comportements et des mobilités, 78000, Versailles, France.
Université de Paris, Laboratoire Mémoire, Cerveau et Cognition, 92100, Boulogne Billancourt, France.
Psychol Res. 2021 Oct;85(7):2636-2653. doi: 10.1007/s00426-020-01427-9. Epub 2020 Oct 9.
Using new developments of interference paradigm, this paper addresses the raising question of the involvement of sensory-motor information in the construction of elaborate spatial models (Johnson-Laird in Mental models: towards a cognitive science of language, inference, and consciousness Cambridge University Press Cambridge, 1983). In two experiments, 112 participants had to explore and memorize the spatial arrangement of 12 objects, disposed on 3 tables. Participants were either sighted or blindfolded, leading to a visual or a more sensory-motor based exploration of the room. During exploration, participants were required to perform a classical verbal, a visuo-spatial dual task or none. In the second experiment, more exploratory, we draw on interference paradigm literature and its recent development in the embodied field to develop two original dual tasks meant to interfere directly with the acquisition of sensory-motor information (haptic and action). After this learning phase, five tasks addressing spatial memory and reasoning used in the construction of spatial models were performed. Results showed classical effects for both verbal and visuo-spatial tasks for sighted participants, but not for blindfolded sighted ones, suggesting that a temporary visual deprivation led participants to use other way to build their spatial models. Our second experiment confirmed this point by showing effect of both sensory-motor dual tasks, especially for blindfolded sighted participants. Taking together, our results support a multimodal view of spatial models, and that exploration modality will influence the information used to construct them. Moreover, this challenges the Baddeley's dualist view of working memory as a reference to theorize the construction of spatial models and provide new experimental evidences towards an embodied view of spatial models.
本文利用新的干扰范式发展,探讨了感官运动信息在精细空间模型构建中的作用这一日益突出的问题(Johnson-Laird,1983,《心理模型:语言、推理和意识的认知科学》,剑桥大学出版社,剑桥)。在两个实验中,112 名参与者需要探索和记忆 12 个物体在 3 张桌子上的空间排列。参与者要么看得见,要么蒙住眼睛,导致对房间的视觉或更基于感官运动的探索。在探索过程中,要求参与者执行经典的口头、视空间双重任务或不执行任务。在第二个实验中,我们借鉴了干扰范式文献及其在具身领域的最新发展,设计了两个原创的双重任务,旨在直接干扰感官运动信息(触觉和动作)的获取。在这个学习阶段之后,进行了五个任务,用于评估构建空间模型时的空间记忆和推理。结果表明,对于看得见的参与者,口头和视空间任务都有经典的效果,但对于蒙住眼睛的看得见的参与者则没有,这表明暂时的视觉剥夺导致参与者使用其他方式构建他们的空间模型。我们的第二个实验通过显示两个感官运动双重任务的效果进一步证实了这一点,尤其是对于蒙住眼睛的看得见的参与者。综上所述,我们的结果支持空间模型的多模态观点,并且探索模式将影响用于构建它们的信息。此外,这对 Baddeley 的工作记忆二元论观点提出了挑战,为空间模型的构建提供了理论参考,并提供了新的实验证据,支持空间模型的具身观点。