IEEE Trans Neural Syst Rehabil Eng. 2021;29:21-30. doi: 10.1109/TNSRE.2020.3029873. Epub 2021 Feb 25.
In myoelectric machine learning (ML) based control, it has been demonstrated that control performance usually increases with training, but it remains largely unknown which underlying factors govern these improvements. It has been suggested that the increase in performance originates from changes in characteristics of the Electromyography (EMG) patterns, such as separability or repeatability. However, the relation between these EMG metrics and control performance has hardly been studied. We assessed the relation between three common EMG feature space metrics (separability, variability and repeatability) in 20 able bodied participants who learned ML myoelectric control in a virtual task over 15 training blocks on 5 days. We assessed the change in offline and real-time performance, as well as the change of each EMG metric over the training. Subsequently, we assessed the relation between individual EMG metrics and offline and real-time performance via correlation analysis. Last, we tried to predict real-time performance from all EMG metrics via L2-regularized linear regression. Results showed that real-time performance improved with training, but there was no change in offline performance or in any of the EMG metrics. Furthermore, we only found a very low correlation between separability and real-time performance and no correlation between any other EMG metric and real-time performance. Finally, real-time performance could not be successfully predicted from all EMG metrics employing L2-regularized linear regression. We concluded that the three EMG metrics and real-time performance appear to be unrelated.
在基于肌电的机器学习 (ML) 控制中,已经证明控制性能通常随着训练而提高,但哪些潜在因素决定了这些改进仍然很大程度上未知。有人认为,性能的提高源于肌电图 (EMG) 模式特征的变化,例如可分离性或可重复性。然而,这些 EMG 指标与控制性能之间的关系几乎没有被研究过。我们评估了三个常见的 EMG 特征空间指标(可分离性、可变性和可重复性)在 20 名健康参与者中的关系,这些参与者在虚拟任务中学习基于 ML 的肌电控制,在 5 天内进行了 15 个训练块。我们评估了离线和实时性能的变化,以及每个 EMG 指标在训练过程中的变化。随后,我们通过相关分析评估了个体 EMG 指标与离线和实时性能之间的关系。最后,我们试图通过 L2 正则化线性回归从所有 EMG 指标预测实时性能。结果表明,实时性能随着训练而提高,但离线性能或任何 EMG 指标都没有变化。此外,我们只发现可分离性与实时性能之间存在非常低的相关性,而任何其他 EMG 指标与实时性能之间都没有相关性。最后,无法通过 L2 正则化线性回归成功地从所有 EMG 指标预测实时性能。我们得出结论,三个 EMG 指标和实时性能似乎没有关系。