Department of Pediatric Dentistry and Dental Public Health, Faculty of Dentistry, Alexandria University, Egypt.
Alexandria and Mediterranean Research Center, Bibliotheca Alexandrina, Egypt.
East Mediterr Health J. 2020 Sep 24;26(9):1078-1086. doi: 10.26719/emhj.20.008.
Egypt is one of the most populated countries in the Eastern Mediterranean Region with historically large numbers of trained professionals providing services in and outside the country. Data about dentist availability are needed to plan for workforce production and training.
We assessed dentist availability in Egypt including (1) changes over 20 years; (2) spatial distribution; and (3) association with supply, potential demand for care and economic conditions.
In an ecological study (1995-2014), we used data from the Central Agency for Public Mobilization and Statistics. The outcome variable was dentist availability (dentists per 1000 population). The explanatory variables were: (1) population size; (2) number of dental graduates; (3) previous dentist availability; (4) increase in wages; and (5) percentage of population migrating internally seeking jobs. We assessed variation in availability using statistical process control and spatial autocorrelation. The impact of explanatory variables was assessed using general linear models with partial η to measure effect size.
Dentists per 1000 population were randomly distributed over the country and the ratio reached 0.18 in 2014, indicating a shortage despite the increasing number of dental graduates since 1995 (667.1%). Previous dentist availability (η = 0.60) and increase in wages (η = 0.48) had the greatest impact on dentist availability.
Egypt faces a problem of dentist shortage that has not been offset by the increase in dental graduates. Improving the economic conditions and incorporating health care into the national development plan may improve the situation.
埃及是东地中海地区人口最多的国家之一,历史上有大量经过培训的专业人员在国内外提供服务。为了规划劳动力的生产和培训,需要了解牙医的可用性。
我们评估了埃及的牙医可用性,包括(1)20 年来的变化;(2)空间分布;(3)与供应、潜在医疗需求和经济条件的关系。
在一项生态学研究中(1995-2014 年),我们使用了中央公共动员和统计局的数据。因变量为牙医可用性(每 1000 人口的牙医数量)。解释变量为:(1)人口规模;(2)牙科毕业生人数;(3)以前的牙医可用性;(4)工资增长;(5)内部寻找工作的人口迁移百分比。我们使用统计过程控制和空间自相关来评估可用性的变化。使用一般线性模型和偏η来测量效应大小,评估解释变量的影响。
每 1000 人口的牙医数量在全国范围内随机分布,2014 年的比例达到 0.18,表明尽管自 1995 年以来牙科毕业生人数增加了(667.1%),但仍存在短缺现象。以前的牙医可用性(η = 0.60)和工资增长(η = 0.48)对牙医可用性的影响最大。
埃及面临着牙医短缺的问题,而这一问题并没有因牙科毕业生人数的增加而得到缓解。改善经济条件并将医疗保健纳入国家发展计划可能会改善这种情况。