Cirad, TETIS, Montpellier, France.
TETIS, Univ. of Montpellier, APT, Cirad, CNRS, INRAE, Montpellier, France.
PLoS One. 2020 Oct 13;15(10):e0240051. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0240051. eCollection 2020.
Land is a scarce resource and its depletion is related to a combination of demographic and economic factors. Hence, the changes in dietary habits and increase in world population that upturn the food demand, are intertwined with a context of increasing oil prices and rise of green capitalism that in turn impacts the demand in biofuel. A visible indicator of these phenomena is the increase, in recent years, of Large Scale Land Acquisitions (LSLAs) by private companies or states. Such land investments often lead to conflicts with local population and have raised issues regarding people's rights, the role of different production models and land governance. The aim of this work is to show how publicly available data about LSLAs can be modeled into complex network structures, thus showing how the application of advanced network analysis techniques can be used to better understand land trade dynamics. We use data collected by the Land Matrix Initiative on LSLAs to model three land trade networks: a multi-sector network, a network centered on the mining sector and a network centered on the agriculture one. Then we provide an extended analysis of such networks which includes: (i) a structural analysis, (ii) the definition of a score, namely LSLA-score, which allows to rank the countries based on their investing/target role in the land trade network, (iii) an analysis of the land trade context which takes into account the LSLA-score ranking and the correlation between network features and several country development indicators, (iv) an analysis centered on the discover and analysis of network motifs (i.e., recurring patterns in the land trade network), which provides insights into complex and diverse relations between countries. Our analyses showed how the land trade market is massively characterized by a Global North-Global South dynamic, even if the investing power of emerging economies also has a major impact in creating relations between different sub-regions of the world. Moreover, the analyses on the mining and agriculture sectors highlighted how the role of several countries in the trade network may drastically change depending of the investment sector, showing diverse hierarchies between investor, intermediate and target countries.
土地是一种稀缺资源,其耗竭与人口和经济因素有关。因此,饮食习惯的变化和世界人口的增加导致了粮食需求的增加,而这与油价上涨和绿色资本主义的兴起交织在一起,进而影响了生物燃料的需求。这些现象的一个明显迹象是,近年来,私营公司或国家进行的大规模土地收购(LSLAs)有所增加。这种土地投资往往会导致与当地居民的冲突,并引发了关于人民权利、不同生产模式和土地治理作用的问题。这项工作的目的是展示如何将关于 LSLAs 的公开数据建模为复杂的网络结构,从而展示如何应用先进的网络分析技术来更好地了解土地交易动态。我们使用土地矩阵倡议收集的关于 LSLAs 的数据来构建三个土地交易网络:一个多部门网络、一个以矿业为中心的网络和一个以农业为中心的网络。然后,我们对这些网络进行了扩展分析,包括:(i)结构分析,(ii)定义一个得分,即 LSLAs 得分,它允许根据它们在土地交易网络中的投资/目标角色对国家进行排名,(iii)分析土地交易背景,其中考虑了 LSLAs 得分排名以及网络特征与几个国家发展指标之间的相关性,(iv)以发现和分析网络模式(即土地交易网络中的重复模式)为中心的分析,这提供了对国家之间复杂多样关系的深入了解。我们的分析表明,土地交易市场在很大程度上具有南北半球动态特征,即使新兴经济体的投资力量也对在世界不同次区域之间建立关系产生了重大影响。此外,对矿业和农业部门的分析强调了几个国家在贸易网络中的作用可能会根据投资部门发生巨大变化,显示出投资者、中间和目标国家之间的不同层次关系。