Complexity and Quantitative Linguistics Lab, Institut de Ciències de l'Educació, Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya, Av. Doctor Marañón 44-50, Barcelona 08028, Catalonia, Spain.
Language and Speech Laboratory, Universidad del País Vasco, Justo Vélez de Elorriaga Kalea, 1, 01006 Vitoria, Spain.
Biol Lett. 2022 Jul;18(7):20220162. doi: 10.1098/rsbl.2022.0162. Epub 2022 Jul 27.
Compression has been presented as a general principle of animal communication. Zipf's Law of brevity is a manifestation of this postulate and can be generalized as the tendency of more frequent communicative elements to be shorter. Previous works supported this claim, showing evidence of Zipf's Law of brevity in animal acoustical communication and human language. However, a significant part of the communicative effort in biological systems is carried out in other transmission channels, such as those based on infochemicals. To fill this gap, we seek, for the first time, evidence of this principle in infochemical communication by analysing the statistical tendency of more frequent infochemicals to be chemically shorter and lighter. We analyse data from the largest and most comprehensive open-access infochemical database known as Pherobase, recovering Zipf's Law of brevity in interspecific communication (allelochemicals) but not in intraspecific communication (pheromones). Moreover, these results are robust even when addressing different magnitudes of study or mathematical approaches. Therefore, different dynamics from the compression principle would dominate intraspecific chemical communication, defying the universality of Zipf's Law of brevity. To conclude, we discuss the exception found for pheromones in the light of other potential communicative paradigms such as pressures on successful communication or the Handicap principle.
压缩被认为是动物交流的一般原则。齐夫简短律是这一假设的表现,可以概括为更频繁的交际元素更短的趋势。以前的工作支持了这一说法,在动物声学交流和人类语言中都证明了简短律的存在。然而,生物系统中很大一部分的交流努力是通过其他传输渠道进行的,例如基于信息素的渠道。为了填补这一空白,我们首次通过分析更频繁的信息素在化学上更短、更轻的统计趋势,寻求在信息素交流中存在这一原则的证据。我们分析了已知最大和最全面的开放访问信息素数据库 Pherobase 的数据,在种间交流(异种信息素)中恢复了简短律,但在种内交流(信息素)中没有。此外,即使在处理不同的研究规模或数学方法时,这些结果也是稳健的。因此,与压缩原理不同的动态将主导种内化学交流,违背了简短律的普遍性。最后,我们根据成功交流的压力或 handicap 原则等其他潜在交流范式,讨论了信息素的例外情况。