Leonard Laurence B, Deevy Patricia
Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN.
J Speech Lang Hear Res. 2020 Oct 16;63(10):3252-3262. doi: 10.1044/2020_JSLHR-20-00006.
Purpose In this article, we review the role of retrieval practice on the word learning and retention of children with specific language impairment (SLI). Method Following a brief review of earlier findings on word learning in children with SLI and the assumptions behind retrieval practice, four experiments are described that compared novel words learned in a repeated spaced retrieval condition and those learned in either a repeated study condition or a repeated immediate retrieval condition. Preschool-age children with SLI and their same-age peers with typical language development were the participants in all experiments. The effects of repeated spaced retrieval were assessed through measures of recall of word form and meaning and, receptively, through both picture-pointing and electrophysiological measures. Results Repeated spaced retrieval resulted in greater recall of word form and meaning across the experiments. This advantage was seen not only for word-picture pairs used during the learning period but also when generalization of the word to new pictures was required. Receptive testing through picture pointing showed similar results, though in some experiments, ceiling effects rendered this measure less sensitive to differences. An alternative receptive measure-the N400 elicited during picture-word mismatches-showed evidence at the neural level favoring repeated spaced retrieval. The advantages of repeated spaced retrieval were seen in both children with SLI and their typically developing age mates. Conclusion Future efforts are warranted to refine and extend the experiments reviewed here. If these efforts prove successful, procedures that incorporate repeated spaced retrieval into more naturalistic clinical and educational activities might be an appropriate next step. Presentation Video https://doi.org/10.23641/asha.13063730.
目的 在本文中,我们回顾了检索练习在特定语言障碍(SLI)儿童单词学习和记忆方面的作用。方法 在简要回顾了早期关于SLI儿童单词学习的研究结果以及检索练习背后的假设之后,描述了四项实验,这些实验比较了在重复间隔检索条件下学习的新单词与在重复学习条件或重复即时检索条件下学习的新单词。患有SLI的学龄前儿童及其具有典型语言发展的同龄同伴是所有实验的参与者。通过单词形式和意义的回忆测量来评估重复间隔检索的效果,并且通过图片指认和电生理测量来进行接受性评估。结果 在所有实验中,重复间隔检索导致对单词形式和意义的回忆更好。这种优势不仅体现在学习期间使用的单词 - 图片对上,而且在需要将单词推广到新图片时也能看到。通过图片指认进行的接受性测试显示了类似的结果,尽管在一些实验中,天花板效应使该测量对差异不太敏感。另一种接受性测量方法——在图片 - 单词不匹配期间诱发的N400——在神经层面显示出有利于重复间隔检索的证据。在患有SLI的儿童及其发育正常的同龄伙伴中都发现了重复间隔检索的优势。结论 有必要进一步完善和扩展本文所回顾的实验。如果这些努力取得成功,将重复间隔检索纳入更自然的临床和教育活动的程序可能是合适的下一步。展示视频https://doi.org/10.23641/asha.13063730 。