Downes Kate, Borry Pascal, Ericson Katrin, Gomez Keith, Greinacher Andreas, Lambert Michele, Leinoe Eva, Noris Patrizia, Van Geet Chris, Freson Kathleen
East Genomic Laboratory Hub, Cambridge University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, Cambridge, UK.
Department of Haematology, University of Cambridge, Cambridge Biomedical Campus, Cambridge, UK.
J Thromb Haemost. 2020 Oct;18(10):2751-2758. doi: 10.1111/jth.14993.
Molecular diagnostics of inherited platelet disorders (IPD) has been revolutionized by the implementation of high-throughput sequencing (HTS) approaches. A conclusive diagnosis using HTS tests can be obtained quickly and cost-effectively in many, but not all patients. The expanding use of HTS tests has raised concerns regarding complex variant interpretation and the ethical implications of detecting unsolicited findings such as variants in IPD genes RUNX1, ETV6, and ANKRD26, which are associated with increased leukemic risk. This guidance document has been developed and written by a multidisciplinary team of researchers and clinicians, with expertise in hematology, clinical and molecular genetics, and bioethics, alongside a RUNX1 patient advocacy representative. We recommend that for clinical diagnostics, HTS for IPD should use a multigene panel of curated diagnostic-grade genes. Critically, we advise that an HTS test for clinical diagnostics should only be ordered by a clinical expert that is: (a) fully aware of the complexity of genotype-phenotype correlations for IPD; (b) able to discuss these complexities with a patient and family members before the test is initiated; and (c) able to interpret and appropriately communicate the results of a HTS diagnostic report, including the implication of variants of uncertain clinical significance. Each patient should know what an HTS test could mean for his or her clinical management before initiating a test. We hereby propose an exemplified informed consent document that includes information on these ethical concerns and can be used by the community for implementation of HTS of IPD in a clinical diagnostic setting. This paper does not include recommendations for HTS of IPD in a research setting.
高通量测序(HTS)方法的应用彻底改变了遗传性血小板疾病(IPD)的分子诊断。使用HTS检测可以在许多(但并非所有)患者中快速且经济高效地获得确定性诊断。HTS检测的广泛使用引发了对复杂变异解读以及检测到意外发现(如IPD基因RUNX1、ETV6和ANKRD26中的变异,这些变异与白血病风险增加相关)的伦理影响的担忧。本指导文件由一个多学科研究人员和临床医生团队编写,他们在血液学、临床和分子遗传学以及生物伦理学方面具有专业知识,还有一位RUNX1患者权益倡导代表参与。我们建议,对于临床诊断,IPD的HTS应使用一组经过筛选的诊断级基因的多基因检测板。至关重要的是,我们建议临床诊断的HTS检测仅应由具备以下条件的临床专家开具:(a)充分了解IPD基因型 - 表型相关性的复杂性;(b)能够在检测开始前与患者及其家属讨论这些复杂性;(c)能够解读并适当地传达HTS诊断报告的结果,包括不确定临床意义变异的含义。每位患者在开始检测前都应了解HTS检测对其临床管理可能意味着什么。我们在此提出一份示例知情同意文件,其中包含有关这些伦理问题的信息,可供社区在临床诊断环境中实施IPD的HTS时使用。本文不包括在研究环境中IPD的HTS建议。