School of Psychology, University of New England, Armidale, NSW, Australia.
Research School of Computer Science, Australian National University, Canberra, ACT, Australia.
Atten Percept Psychophys. 2021 Jan;83(1):435-447. doi: 10.3758/s13414-020-02128-6.
Weber's law predicts that stimulus sensitivity will increase proportionally with increases in stimulus intensity. Does this hold for the stimulus of time - specifically, duration in the milliseconds to seconds range? There is conflicting evidence on the relationship between temporal sensitivity and duration. Weber's law predicts a linear relationship between sensitivity and duration on interval timing tasks, while two alternative models predict a reverse J-shaped and a U-shaped relationship. Based on previous research, we hypothesised that temporal sensitivity in humans would follow a U-shaped function, increasing and then decreasing with increases in duration, and that this model would provide a better statistical fit to the data than the reverse-J or the simple Weber's Law model. In a two-alternative forced-choice interval comparison task, 24 participants made duration judgements about six groups of auditory intervals between 100 and 3,200 ms. Weber fractions were generated for each group of intervals and plotted against time to generate a function describing sensitivity to the stimulus of duration. Although the sensitivity function was slightly concave, and the model describing a U-shaped function gave the best fit to the data, the increase in the model fit was not sufficient to warrant the extra free parameter in the chosen model. Further analysis demonstrated that Weber's law itself provided a better description of sensitivity to changes in duration than either of the two models tested.
韦伯定律预测刺激敏感度将与刺激强度成比例增加。这对于时间刺激是否成立——特别是在毫秒到秒的范围内的持续时间?关于时间敏感度和持续时间之间的关系存在相互矛盾的证据。韦伯定律预测在间隔时间任务中,敏感性和持续时间之间存在线性关系,而两种替代模型预测反向 J 形和 U 形关系。基于先前的研究,我们假设人类的时间敏感度将遵循 U 形函数,随着持续时间的增加而增加然后减少,并且该模型将比反向 J 形或简单的韦伯定律模型更好地拟合数据。在二选一强制选择间隔比较任务中,24 名参与者对 100 到 3200 毫秒之间的六个听觉间隔组进行了持续时间判断。为每组间隔生成韦伯分数,并绘制时间图以生成描述对持续时间刺激的敏感性的函数。尽管灵敏度函数略有凹形,描述 U 形函数的模型最能拟合数据,但模型拟合的增加不足以证明所选模型中额外自由参数的合理性。进一步的分析表明,韦伯定律本身比测试的两种模型中的任何一种都能更好地描述对持续时间变化的敏感性。