Suddaby L, Weir B, Forsyth C
Division of Neurosurgery, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Canada.
Can J Neurol Sci. 1987 Aug;14(3):268-72. doi: 10.1017/s0317167100026597.
We analyzed the charts and CT scans of 49 cases of civilian .22 caliber gunshot wounds of the brain admitted to the University of Alberta and Royal Alexandra Hospitals between 1975 and 1985. The average age of the patients was 30 years, 88% were males, 88% were suicide attempts. There were no deaths among patients with an initial coma score above 12 whereas the mortality rate was 85% for those admitted with a score of 7 or less. All those with fixed pupils on admission died. The overall mortality rate of 61% is comparable to that of other series of civilian gunshot wounds including those in which more aggressive surgical management was undertaken. We recommend that no treatment be given those cases with an admission coma score of 3 and/or fixed pupils and that simple scalp wound debridement be employed with those having a coma score of 7 or less. Tract exploration and retrieval of bullet fragments is not indicated, as retained fragments carry a very low incidence of complications (e.g. abscess formation). In patients in good condition (GCS greater than or equal to 12) the management of intracranial hematomas should be independent of their etiology and approached aggressively.
我们分析了1975年至1985年间收治于阿尔伯塔大学和皇家亚历山德拉医院的49例民用.22口径脑部枪伤患者的病历及CT扫描结果。患者的平均年龄为30岁,88%为男性,88%是自杀未遂。初始昏迷评分为12分以上的患者无死亡病例,而入院时评分为7分及以下的患者死亡率为85%。所有入院时瞳孔固定的患者均死亡。61%的总体死亡率与其他一系列民用枪伤病例的死亡率相当,包括那些采用了更积极手术治疗的病例。我们建议,对于入院昏迷评分为3分和/或瞳孔固定的病例不进行治疗,对于昏迷评分为7分及以下的患者采用简单的头皮伤口清创术。不建议进行弹道探查和取出子弹碎片,因为残留碎片引发并发症(如脓肿形成)的发生率非常低。对于状况良好(格拉斯哥昏迷评分大于或等于12分)的患者,颅内血肿的处理应与其病因无关,并积极进行。