Sun Zhongyi, Wu Lin, Liu Zhixiong, Zhong Weiming, Kou Zhifeng, Liu Jinfang
Department of Neurosurgery, Xiangya Hospital, Central South University, Changsha, China.
Department of Ophthalmology and Anatomy and Cell Biology, Wayne State University, Detroit, MI, USA.
Quant Imaging Med Surg. 2020 Nov;10(11):2144-2156. doi: 10.21037/qims-20-128.
Intracranial pressure (ICP) monitoring in traumatic brain injury (TBI) usually requires the placement of a catheter into the ipsilateral ventricle. This surgical procedure is commonly performed via a freehand method using surface anatomical landmarks as guides. The current accuracy of the catheter placement remains relatively low and even lower among TBI patients. This study was undertaken to optimize the freehand ventricular cannulation to increase the accuracy for TBI. The authors hypothesized that an optimal surgical plan of cannulation should give an operator the greatest degrees of freedom, which could be measured as the range of operation angle, range of catheter placement depth, and size of the target area.
An imaging simulation was first performed using the computed tomography (CT) images of 47 adult patients with normal brain anatomy. On the reconstructed 3D head model, four different coronal planes of ventricular cannulation were identified: a 4-cm anterior, a 2-cm anterior, a standard (central), and a 2-cm posterior plane. The degrees of freedom during the cannulation procedure were determined, including the relevant angles, lengths of cannulation, cross-sectional area, and bounding rectangle of the lateral ventricle. Next, a retrospective assessment was performed on the CT scans of another 111 patients with TBI who underwent freehand ventricular cannulation for ICP monitoring. Postoperative measurements were also performed based on CT images to calculate the accuracy and safety of catheter placement between coronal planes in practice.
Our simulation results showed that the 2-cm anterior plane had more extensive degrees of freedom for ventricular cannulation, in terms of length of catheter trajectory (7% longer, P<0.001), cross-sectional area of the lateral ventricle (14% larger, P=0.046), and length of the lateral ventricle (17% wider, P<0.001) than that of the standard plane, while both the 4-cm anterior and 2-cm posterior planes did not offer advantages over the standard plane in these ways. The mean length range of catheter trajectory in the 2-cm anterior plane was 41 to 58 mm. Retrospective assessment of TBI patients with ICP monitor placement also confirmed our simulation data. It showed that the accuracy of ipsilateral ventricle cannulation in the 2-cm anterior plane was 70.6%, which was a significant increase from 42.9% in the standard plane (P=0.007).
Our imaging simulation and retrospective study demonstrate that different coronal planes could provide different degrees of freedom for cannulation, the 2-cm anterior plane has the greatest degrees of freedom in terms of larger target area and greater length range of the trajectory. The optimized surgical plan in this manner could improve cannulation accuracy and benefit a significant number of TBI patients.
创伤性脑损伤(TBI)患者的颅内压(ICP)监测通常需要将导管置入同侧脑室。该手术通常通过徒手方法,以表面解剖标志为引导进行。目前导管置入的准确性仍然相对较低,在TBI患者中甚至更低。本研究旨在优化徒手脑室置管术,以提高TBI患者的置管准确性。作者假设,最佳的置管手术方案应给予操作者最大程度的自由度,这可以通过手术角度范围、导管置入深度范围和目标区域大小来衡量。
首先使用47例脑解剖结构正常的成年患者的计算机断层扫描(CT)图像进行成像模拟。在重建的三维头部模型上,确定了四个不同的脑室置管冠状平面:前4cm平面、前2cm平面、标准(中央)平面和后2cm平面。确定了置管过程中的自由度,包括相关角度、置管长度、横截面积以及侧脑室的边界矩形。接下来,对另外111例接受徒手脑室置管进行ICP监测的TBI患者的CT扫描进行回顾性评估。还基于CT图像进行术后测量,以计算实际操作中冠状平面之间导管置入的准确性和安全性。
我们的模拟结果表明,在前2cm平面进行脑室置管时,导管轨迹长度(长7%,P<0.001)、侧脑室横截面积(大14%,P=0.046)和侧脑室长度(宽17%,P<0.001)方面具有更广泛的自由度,而前4cm平面和后2cm平面在这些方面均未比标准平面具有优势。前2cm平面导管轨迹的平均长度范围为41至58mm。对放置ICP监测器的TBI患者的回顾性评估也证实了我们的模拟数据。结果显示,前2cm平面同侧脑室置管的准确性为70.6%,较标准平面的42.9%有显著提高(P=0.007)。
我们的成像模拟和回顾性研究表明,不同的冠状平面可为置管提供不同程度的自由度,前2cm平面在目标区域较大和轨迹长度范围更大方面具有最大的自由度。以这种方式优化手术方案可提高置管准确性,并使大量TBI患者受益。