Colmers-Gray Isabelle N, Ha David J, Tan Maria C, Dong Sandy L
Department of Emergency Medicine University of Alberta Edmonton Alberta Canada.
John W. Scott Health Sciences Library University of Alberta Edmonton Alberta Canada.
AEM Educ Train. 2020 Feb 28;4(4):428-432. doi: 10.1002/aet2.10437. eCollection 2020 Oct.
Evidence-based medicine (EBM) and literature searching skills are competencies within the emergency medicine (EM) residency curriculum. Previously in our residency program, a librarian taught literature searching instruction, including a classroom-based overview of search engines. Learners reported low engagement and poor retention. To improve engagement, interest, and skill retention, we used a novel approach: simulation to teach real-time literature searching.
Based on a needs assessment of our EM residents, we created a literature searching workshop using a flipped classroom approach and high-fidelity simulation. Goals of the session were to be interactive, engaging, and practice-relevant. With a librarian, we developed a brief list of EM-relevant databases, including tips for searching and links to sites/apps. Prereadings also covered the hierarchy of evidence and formulating a good clinical (PICO) question. Residents (12 junior residents) participated in a high-fidelity simulation involving a stable patient whose management required a literature search to inform decisions. Feedback was collected on the simulation experience.
Residents received the list of EM-relevant databases 7 days prior and were instructed to set up and test the resources on their smartphones. The day of the session, one resident volunteered to lead the simulation; all residents participated in the search on their smart phones. Collectively, it took 4.5 minutes to find a study that adequately addressed the clinical question and to manage the patient accordingly. Feedback on the simulation was positive. Students found it "very real and practical" and "immediately institutable into practice." It helped residents learn to efficiently and effectively search the literature while managing a stable patient.
A flipped-classroom simulation-based teaching strategy made learning literature searching more interesting, engaging, and applicable to EM practice. Based on popular demand, we will continue to use this teaching method.
循证医学(EBM)和文献检索技能是急诊医学(EM)住院医师培训课程中的能力要求。在我们之前的住院医师培训项目中,由一名图书馆员讲授文献检索指导,包括在课堂上对搜索引擎进行概述。学员们反馈参与度低且记忆效果差。为了提高参与度、兴趣和技能保留率,我们采用了一种新颖的方法:通过模拟来教授实时文献检索。
基于对我们急诊医学住院医师的需求评估,我们采用翻转课堂的方法和高保真模拟创建了一个文献检索工作坊。该课程的目标是具有互动性、趣味性且与实践相关。我们与一名图书馆员共同制定了一份简短的与急诊医学相关的数据库清单,包括搜索提示以及网站/应用程序的链接。预习内容还涵盖了证据等级和制定良好的临床(PICO)问题。住院医师(12名初级住院医师)参与了一次高保真模拟,模拟场景是一名病情稳定的患者,其治疗需要通过文献检索来辅助决策。我们收集了关于模拟体验的反馈。
住院医师在课程前7天收到了与急诊医学相关的数据库清单,并被要求在他们的智能手机上设置并测试这些资源。课程当天,一名住院医师自愿主持模拟;所有住院医师都在智能手机上参与了检索。总共用时4.5分钟就找到了一项充分解决临床问题的研究,并据此对患者进行了治疗。对模拟的反馈是积极的。学生们认为它“非常真实且实用”,并且“可以立即应用于实践”。它帮助住院医师在管理病情稳定的患者的同时,学会高效且有效地检索文献。
基于翻转课堂模拟的教学策略使文献检索学习变得更有趣、更具吸引力且适用于急诊医学实践。基于广泛需求,我们将继续使用这种教学方法。