Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN, USA.
University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA.
Risk Anal. 2021 Sep;41(9):1614-1629. doi: 10.1111/risa.13633. Epub 2020 Nov 10.
Previous research suggests that when individuals have limited knowledge to make sense of new or emerging technologies, they may rely more on available cues, such as the fairness of those managing the risks, when developing their attitudinal and behavioral responses to the technology. To examine this further, we designed an online experiment (N = 1,042) to test the effects of risk managers' nonoutcome fairness on individuals' selective exposure to additional information and perceived risk. As the study context, we used the development of enhanced geothermal systems (EGS), which uses drilling to tap deep underground sources of heat for district heating and electricity and remains low in familiarity among the U.S. public. The results suggest that participants who read about the fair risk manager were subsequently more likely to have positive attitudes toward EGS development. In turn, those with more positive attitudes were more likely to select and read positively valenced articles about EGS, resulting in an indirect effect of the fairness condition. Although this study also explored whether uncertainty moderated this fairness effect on information seeking, it found no evidence. Additionally, when participants were exposed to information featuring fair risk managers, perceived risk decreased, an effect that was mediated by beliefs that EGS was controllable and not dreadful. These results underscore the importance of using practices that will increase nonoutcome fairness in the introduction of new technologies.
先前的研究表明,当个人对新技术或新兴技术的了解有限时,他们在形成对该技术的态度和行为反应时,可能会更多地依赖于可用的线索,例如管理风险的人的公正性。为了进一步研究这一点,我们设计了一个在线实验(N=1042),以测试风险管理者的非结果公正性对个人对额外信息的选择性接触和感知风险的影响。作为研究背景,我们使用增强型地热系统(EGS)的开发为例,该系统利用钻探技术从地下深处获取热量,用于区域供热和发电,在美国公众中还不太熟悉。结果表明,阅读公正风险管理者的参与者随后更有可能对 EGS 开发持积极态度。反过来,那些态度更为积极的人更有可能选择并阅读有关 EGS 的正面文章,从而对公正性条件产生间接影响。尽管这项研究还探讨了不确定性是否会调节信息寻求中的这种公正性效应,但并未发现证据。此外,当参与者接触到公正的风险管理者提供的信息时,感知风险会降低,这一效应是通过相信 EGS 是可控的且不可怕的信念来介导的。这些结果强调了在引入新技术时采用提高非结果公正性的做法的重要性。