Taylor Jonathan, Fenner John
Sheffield Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, Sheffield, UK.
University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK.
BJR Open. 2018 Nov 23;1(1):20180017. doi: 10.1259/bjro.20180017. eCollection 2019.
Machine learning promises much in the field of radiology, both in terms of software that can directly analyse patient data and algorithms that can automatically perform other processes in the reporting pipeline. However, clinical practice remains largely untouched by such technology. This article highlights what we consider to be the major obstacles to widespread clinical adoption of machine learning software, namely: representative data and evidence, regulations, health economics, heterogeneity of the clinical environment and support and promotion. We argue that these issues are currently so substantial that machine learning will struggle to find acceptance beyond the narrow group of applications where the potential benefits are readily evident. In order that machine learning can fulfil its potential in radiology, a radical new approach is needed, where significant resources are directed at reducing impediments to translation rather than always being focused solely on development of the technology itself.
机器学习在放射学领域前景广阔,无论是在可直接分析患者数据的软件方面,还是在能自动执行报告流程中其他环节的算法方面。然而,此类技术在很大程度上仍未触及临床实践。本文重点阐述了我们认为机器学习软件在临床广泛应用的主要障碍,即:代表性数据与证据、法规、卫生经济学、临床环境的异质性以及支持与推广。我们认为,目前这些问题非常严重,以至于机器学习将难以在潜在益处显而易见的狭窄应用领域之外获得认可。为了使机器学习能够在放射学中发挥其潜力,需要一种全新的方法,即投入大量资源来减少转化障碍,而不是一直仅仅专注于技术本身的开发。