Department of Economics Marco Biagi, University of Modena and Reggio Emilia, Modena, Italy.
Department of Epidemiology, ASL TO3, Grugliasco, Italy.
Ergonomics. 2021 Apr;64(4):512-520. doi: 10.1080/00140139.2020.1850881. Epub 2020 Dec 1.
Aim of the study was to estimate agreement between observational and interview-based exposure to ergonomic factors at work. Thirty-two male workers employed in a logistics hub were interviewed through the OCRA check-list on exposure to ergonomic factors in one of six work tasks. Observations of workers in each work task, based on the same OCRA check-list, were used to assess exposure in that task. Agreement between observed and interview-based scores of the check-list OCRA index, as well as of frequency and posture, was estimated both at individual and task group level through the Intraclass Correlation Coefficient (ICC). At work task level, high concordance was found between observed and interview-based scores for all the exposures examined, while at the individual level agreement was moderate. These results suggest that exposure assessment through interviews based on the OCRA check-list is a valid method, which could be used as a workstation screening tool. The study aimed to evaluate agreement between observational and interview-based exposure to ergonomic factors at work, assessed through the OCRA check-list on 32 male workers. Agreement was found at least moderate, suggesting that interview-based exposure assessed through the OCRA check-list could be used as a proxy of observations for workstation screening. ART: assessment of repetitive tasks; CI: confidence intervals; EAWS: European assembly worksheet; ICC: intraclass correlation coefficient; ISO: International Standards Organization; OCRA: occupational repetitive actions; ULRA: upper limb risk assessment; WUEMSDs: work-related upper extremity musculoskeletal disorders.
研究目的是评估基于观察和访谈的工作中人体工程学因素暴露的一致性。32 名男性工人在物流中心工作,在 6 项工作任务之一中通过 OCRA 检查表接受了关于人体工程学因素暴露的访谈。基于相同的 OCRA 检查表,对每个工作任务中的工人进行观察,以评估该任务中的暴露情况。通过组内相关系数 (ICC) 分别在个体和任务组水平上评估观察和基于访谈的 OCRA 检查表指数、频率和姿势得分之间的一致性。在工作任务水平上,对于所有检查的暴露,观察和基于访谈的得分之间存在高度一致性,而在个体水平上,一致性为中度。这些结果表明,基于 OCRA 检查表的访谈进行的暴露评估是一种有效的方法,可以用作工作站筛选工具。本研究旨在通过 OCRA 检查表评估 32 名男性工人的工作中人体工程学因素的观察和访谈暴露,并评估其一致性。结果表明至少存在中度一致性,表明通过 OCRA 检查表进行的基于访谈的暴露评估可以作为工作站筛查的观察代理。ART:评估重复性任务;CI:置信区间;EAWS:欧洲装配工作表;ICC:组内相关系数;ISO:国际标准组织;OCRA:职业重复性动作;ULRA:上肢风险评估;WUEMSDs:与工作相关的上肢肌肉骨骼疾病。