URAFPA, University of Lorraine-INRAe, 54500, Vandoeuvre, France; Faculty of Geography and Environmental Sciences, Al-Farabi Kazakh National University, 050040, Almaty, Kazakhstan; Antigen LLP, Scientific and Production Enterprise, 040905, Almaty Region, Kazakhstan.
URAFPA, University of Lorraine-INRAe, 54500, Vandoeuvre, France.
Chemosphere. 2021 Jan;262:128351. doi: 10.1016/j.chemosphere.2020.128351. Epub 2020 Sep 16.
The transfer of POPs in food of animal origin has been studied by a meta-analysis of 28 peer-reviewed articles using transfer rate (TR) for milk and eggs and bioconcentration factors (BCF) for eligible tissues after establishing an adapted methodology. TRs of the most toxic PCDD/Fs into milk were generally elevated and even higher into eggs. BCFs in excreting adult animals varied widely between studies complicating to hierarchize tissues or congeners, even if liver and fat seemed to bioconcentrate more than lean tissues. Short time studies have clearly shown low BCFs contrarily to field studies showing the highest BCFs. The BCFs of PCDD/Fs in growing animals were higher in liver than in fat or muscle. In contrast to easily bioconcentrating hexachlorinated congeners, octa- and heptachlorinated congeners barely bioconcentrate. PCB transfer into milk and eggs was systematically high for very lipophilic congeners. Highly ortho-chlorinated PCBs were transferred >50% into milk and eggs and even >70% for congeners 123 and 167 into eggs. BCFs of the most toxic PCBs 126 and 169 were significantly higher than for less toxic congeners. BCFs seem generally low in PBDEs except congeners 47, 153 and 154. DDT and its metabolites showed high bioconcentration. Differences between tissues appeared but were masked by a study effect. In addition to some methodologic recommendations, this analysis showed the high transfer of POPs into eggs, milk and liver when animals were exposed justifying a strong monitoring in areas with POP exposure.
采用适应方法,通过对 28 篇同行评审文章的荟萃分析,研究了 POPs 在动物源食品中的转移。该方法使用了牛奶中的转移率(TR)和合适组织中的生物浓缩因子(BCF)来研究最毒的 PCDD/F 向牛奶中的转移,结果表明其转移率通常较高,向鸡蛋中的转移率更高。在排泄成年动物的组织中,BCF 差异很大,这使得对组织或同系物进行分级变得复杂,即使肝脏和脂肪似乎比瘦组织更易生物浓缩。短期研究清楚地表明,BCF 较低,与表明最高 BCF 的现场研究相反。生长动物肝脏中的 PCDD/Fs 的 BCF 高于脂肪或肌肉中的 BCF。与易生物浓缩的六氯同系物相反,八氯和七氯同系物几乎不易生物浓缩。非常亲脂的同系物会系统性地将 PCB 转移到牛奶和鸡蛋中。高度邻位氯化的 PCBs 有超过 50%转移到牛奶和鸡蛋中,而对于 123 和 167 同系物,甚至有超过 70%转移到鸡蛋中。最毒的 PCBs 126 和 169 的 BCF 明显高于低毒同系物。BCF 似乎在除了 47、153 和 154 以外的多溴联苯醚中普遍较低。DDT 及其代谢物显示出高生物浓缩性。组织之间存在差异,但被研究效应所掩盖。除了一些方法学建议外,该分析表明,动物暴露时 POPs 向鸡蛋、牛奶和肝脏中的高转移率,这证明在 POP 暴露地区进行强有力的监测是合理的。