Mingins Jessica E, Tarver Joanne, Waite Jane, Jones Chris, Surtees Andrew Dr
University of Birmingham, UK.
Aston University, UK.
Autism. 2021 Jan;25(1):18-32. doi: 10.1177/1362361320953253. Epub 2020 Nov 16.
Autistic children often experience higher levels of anxiety than their peers. It can be difficult to diagnose and treat anxiety disorders in autistic children, in part because of the high degree of variability in their underlying abilities and presentations. Some evidence suggests that autistic children with higher intelligence (as measured by intelligence quotient) experience higher levels of anxiety than autistic children with lower intelligence. However, the evidence is inconsistent, with other papers not finding a difference or finding higher levels of anxiety in autistic children with lower intelligence. In this article, we review existing literature to see whether autistic children with higher intelligence quotients have higher anxiety than autistic children with lower intelligence quotients. A systematic search of the literature was conducted which identified 49 papers on the topic. The methods of all the papers were reviewed using an objective quality assessment framework. When combining the data statistically, there was evidence that autistic children with higher intelligence quotients are more anxious than autistic children with lower intelligence quotients. The quality review raised common weaknesses across studies. Most importantly, few studies used measures of anxiety that have been shown to be valid for children with very low intelligence quotients. Similarly, many studies used measures of anxiety that have not been shown to be valid for autistic children. These factors are important because autistic children and those with low intelligence quotient may experience or understand anxiety differently. Future research should use fully validated measures to test whether high intelligence quotient is associated with high levels of anxiety in autistic children.
自闭症儿童往往比同龄人经历更高水平的焦虑。诊断和治疗自闭症儿童的焦虑症可能很困难,部分原因是他们潜在的能力和表现存在高度变异性。一些证据表明,智商较高的自闭症儿童比智商较低的自闭症儿童经历更高水平的焦虑。然而,证据并不一致,其他论文没有发现差异,或者发现智商较低的自闭症儿童焦虑水平更高。在本文中,我们回顾现有文献,以了解智商较高的自闭症儿童是否比智商较低的自闭症儿童有更高的焦虑。我们对文献进行了系统检索,确定了49篇关于该主题的论文。使用客观质量评估框架对所有论文的方法进行了审查。在对数据进行统计合并时,有证据表明智商较高的自闭症儿童比智商较低的自闭症儿童更焦虑。质量审查揭示了各研究中常见的弱点。最重要的是,很少有研究使用已被证明对智商非常低的儿童有效的焦虑测量方法。同样,许多研究使用的焦虑测量方法尚未被证明对自闭症儿童有效。这些因素很重要,因为自闭症儿童和智商低的儿童可能以不同方式体验或理解焦虑。未来的研究应该使用经过充分验证的测量方法来测试高智商是否与自闭症儿童的高焦虑水平相关。