Cook Michael J, Puri Basant K
Vis a Vis Symposiums, Bury St Edmunds, UK.
CAR, Cambridge, UK.
Infect Dis Model. 2020 Oct 16;5:871-888. doi: 10.1016/j.idm.2020.10.004. eCollection 2020.
Two models were developed to estimate Lyme borreliosis (LB) cases. One was based on the seroprevalence of infections in human samples. This model used corrections for false negative and false positive results from published test sensitivity and specificity measures. A second model based on infections in sentinel dogs was used to quantify the prevalence of Lyme disease infections in humans; the reference baseline for this model was human and canine infections in Germany. A comparison of the two models is shown and differences discussed. The relationships between incidence, prevalence and total infection burden for LB were derived from published data and these were used in both models to calculate annual incidence, prevalence and total LB infections. The modelling was conservative and based on medical insurance records coded for erythema migrans. Linear model growth rates were used in place of the commonly adopted exponential growth. The mean of the two models was used to create estimates for various countries and continents. Examples from the analyses for LB estimated for 2018 include: incidence - USA 473,000/year, Germany 471,000/year, France 434,000/year and UK 132,000/year; prevalence - USA 2.4 million, Germany 2.4 million, France 2.2 million and UK 667,000; total infections - USA 10.1 million, Germany 10.0 million, France 9.3 million and UK 2.8 million. Estimates for the world for 2018 are: incidence 12.3 million/year; prevalence 62.1 million; and total infection burden 262.0 million. These figures are far higher than officially published data and reflect not only the underestimation of diagnosed cases, which is acknowledged by health agencies, but also undiagnosed and misdiagnosed cases.
开发了两种模型来估计莱姆病(LB)病例。一种基于人体样本中感染的血清阳性率。该模型对已发表的检测灵敏度和特异性测量结果中的假阴性和假阳性结果进行了校正。另一种基于哨兵犬感染情况的模型用于量化人类莱姆病感染的患病率;该模型的参考基线是德国的人类和犬类感染情况。展示了两种模型的比较并讨论了差异。莱姆病的发病率、患病率和总感染负担之间的关系来自已发表的数据,这些数据在两种模型中均用于计算年度发病率、患病率和莱姆病总感染数。建模是保守的,基于为游走性红斑编码的医疗保险记录。使用线性模型增长率代替常用的指数增长率。两种模型的平均值用于为不同国家和各大洲创建估计值。2018年莱姆病分析的示例包括:发病率——美国每年473,000例、德国每年471,000例、法国每年434,000例和英国每年132,000例;患病率——美国240万例、德国240万例、法国220万例和英国66.7万例;总感染数——美国1010万例、德国1000万例、法国930万例和英国280万例。2018年全球估计值为:发病率每年1230万例;患病率6210万例;总感染负担2.62亿例。这些数字远高于官方公布的数据,不仅反映了卫生机构承认的确诊病例的低估情况,还反映了未确诊和误诊病例的情况。