Sheta Razan, Bachvarova Magdalena, Plante Marie, Renaud Marie-Claude, Sebastianelli Alexandra, Gregoire Jean, Navarro Jamilet Miranda, Perez Ricardo Bringas, Masson Jean-Yves, Bachvarov Dimcho
Department of Molecular Medicine, Université Laval, Québec, QC, G1V 0A6, Canada.
Centre de recherche du CHU de Québec, Oncology division, L'Hôtel-Dieu de Québec, 9 rue McMahon, Québec, QC, G1R 3S3, Canada.
J Transl Med. 2020 Nov 19;18(1):439. doi: 10.1186/s12967-020-02613-4.
Poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase inhibitors (PARPis) specifically target homologous recombination deficiency (HRD) cells and display good therapeutic effect in women with advanced-stage BRCA1/2-mutated breast and epithelial ovarian cancer (EOC). However, about 50% of high grade serous ovarian cancers (HGSOC) present with HRD due to epigenetic BRCA1 inactivation, as well as genetic/epigenetic inactivation(s) of other HR genes, a feature known as "BRCAness". Therefore, there is a potential for extending the use of PARPis to these patients if HR status can be identified.
We have developed a 3D (spheroid) functional assay to assess the sensitivity of two PARPis (niraparib and olaparib) in ascites-derived primary cell cultures (AsPCs) from HGSOC patients. A method for AsPCs preparation was established based on a matrix (agarose), allowing for easy isolation and successive propagation of monolayer and 3D AsPCs. Based on this method, we performed cytotoxicity assays on 42 AsPCs grown both as monolayers and spheroids.
The response to PARPis treatment in monolayer AsPCs, was significantly higher, compared to 3D AsPCs, as 88% and 52% of the monolayer AsPCs displayed sensitivity to niraparib and olaparib respectively, while 66% of the 3D AsPCs were sensitive to niraparib and 38% to olaparib, the latter being more consistent with previous estimates of HRD (40%-60%) in EOC. Moreover, niraparib displayed a significantly stronger cytotoxic effect in both in 3D and monolayer AsPCs, which was confirmed by consecutive analyses of the HR pathway activity (γH2AX foci formation) in PARPis-sensitive and resistant AsPCs. Global gene expression comparison of 6 PARPi-resistant and 6 PARPi-sensitive 3D AsPCs was indicative for the predominant downregulation of numerous genes and networks with previously demonstrated roles in EOC chemoresistance, suggesting that the PARPis-sensitive AsPCs could display enhanced sensitivity to other chemotherapeutic drugs, commonly applied in cancer management. Microarray data validation identified 24 potential gene biomarkers associated with PARPis sensitivity. The differential expression of 7 selected biomarkers was consecutively confirmed by immunohistochemistry in matched EOC tumor samples.
The application of this assay and the potential biomarkers with possible predictive significance to PARPis therapy of EOC patients now need testing in the setting of a clinical trial.
聚(ADP - 核糖)聚合酶抑制剂(PARPis)特异性靶向同源重组缺陷(HRD)细胞,在晚期BRCA1/2突变的乳腺癌和上皮性卵巢癌(EOC)女性患者中显示出良好的治疗效果。然而,约50%的高级别浆液性卵巢癌(HGSOC)由于BRCA1的表观遗传失活以及其他HR基因的遗传/表观遗传失活(即“BRCAness”特征)而表现出HRD。因此,如果能够识别HR状态,就有可能将PARPis的使用扩展到这些患者。
我们开发了一种3D(球体)功能测定法,以评估两种PARPis(尼拉帕利和奥拉帕利)对来自HGSOC患者腹水来源的原代细胞培养物(AsPCs)的敏感性。基于一种基质(琼脂糖)建立了AsPCs的制备方法,便于单层和3D AsPCs的轻松分离和连续传代。基于此方法,我们对42个以单层和球体形式生长的AsPCs进行了细胞毒性测定。
与3D AsPCs相比,单层AsPCs对PARPis治疗的反应显著更高,因为分别有88%和52%的单层AsPCs对尼拉帕利和奥拉帕利敏感,而66%的3D AsPCs对尼拉帕利敏感,38%对奥拉帕利敏感,后者更符合先前对EOC中HRD的估计(40%-60%)。此外,尼拉帕利在3D和单层AsPCs中均显示出显著更强的细胞毒性作用,这通过对PARPis敏感和耐药的AsPCs中HR途径活性(γH2AX灶形成)的连续分析得到证实。对6个PARPi耐药和6个PARPi敏感的3D AsPCs进行的全基因表达比较表明,许多先前已证明在EOC化疗耐药中起作用的基因和网络主要下调,这表明PARPis敏感的AsPCs可能对癌症治疗中常用的其他化疗药物表现出更高的敏感性。微阵列数据验证确定了24个与PARPis敏感性相关的潜在基因生物标志物。通过免疫组织化学在匹配的EOC肿瘤样本中连续证实了7个选定生物标志物的差异表达。
现在需要在临床试验中测试该测定法以及对EOC患者PARPis治疗可能具有预测意义的潜在生物标志物的应用。