Department of Social Science & Policy Studies, Worcester Polytechnic Institute, Worcester, Massachusetts, USA.
Department of Psychology, University of California, Los Angeles, California, USA.
Obesity (Silver Spring). 2021 Jan;29(1):226-232. doi: 10.1002/oby.23032. Epub 2020 Nov 20.
The media often contain weight-stigmatizing material. However, little is known about pregnant and postpartum women's experiences with media-based weight stigma.
Two studies investigated weight stigma in the media from multiple perspectives. Study 1 analyzed open-response examples of weight-stigmatizing experiences coming from the media, broadly defined, from 123 pregnant and postpartum women (from a larger sample of 501). Study 2 identified online news-media articles about pregnancy and weight published during the study 1 data collection period (August to November 2017).
Study 1 revealed that weight stigma was common and frequent in media, manifesting across three themes: (1) ideal appearance of pregnant bodies, (2) pressure to quickly "bounce back" after birth to a prepregnancy appearance, and (3) media praising celebrities for achieving either of the previous themes. Study 2 identified 33 articles. A content analysis revealed that women with overweight or obesity were rarely portrayed in images. Additionally, discussion of weight was often negative, focusing on adverse maternal-child health consequences. Finally, media-communicated ideals for weight and weight loss were often unrealistic and did not reference medical guidelines.
This work is the first to document that online news media are a pervasive and potentially distressing source of pregnancy-related weight stigma, suggesting much-needed reform in media guidelines.
媒体中经常包含体重污名化的内容。然而,人们对孕妇和产后女性在媒体中遭遇体重污名化的体验知之甚少。
两项研究从多个角度调查了媒体中的体重污名化现象。研究 1 分析了来自媒体(广义定义)的 123 名孕妇和产后女性(来自更大的 501 名样本)对体重污名化经历的开放式回复示例。研究 2 确定了在研究 1 数据收集期间(2017 年 8 月至 11 月)发布的有关怀孕和体重的在线新闻媒体文章。
研究 1 表明,体重污名化在媒体中很常见且频繁出现,表现为三个主题:(1)孕妇身体的理想外观,(2)产后迅速“恢复”到怀孕前的外观的压力,以及(3)媒体赞扬名人实现上述主题的做法。研究 2 确定了 33 篇文章。内容分析显示,超重或肥胖的女性很少出现在图像中。此外,对体重的讨论往往是负面的,侧重于母婴健康的不良后果。最后,媒体传达的体重和减肥的理想标准往往不切实际,也没有参考医学指南。
这项工作首次记录了在线新闻媒体是与怀孕相关的体重污名化的一个普遍存在且潜在令人痛苦的来源,这表明媒体指南急需改革。