Pieńkowska Joanna R, Manganelli Giuseppe, Giusti Folco, Barbato Debora, Kosicka Ewa, Hallgass Alessandro, Lesicki Andrzej
Department of Cell Biology, Institute of Experimental Biology, Faculty of Biology, Adam Mickiewicz University in Poznan, Uniwersytetu Poznańskiego 6, 61-614 Poznań, Poland Adam Mickiewicz University in Poznan Poznań Poland.
Dipartimento di Scienze Fisiche, della Terra e dell'Ambiente, Università di Siena, Via Mattioli 4, 53100 Siena, Italy Università di Siena Siena Italy.
Zookeys. 2020 Nov 6;988:17-61. doi: 10.3897/zookeys.988.56397. eCollection 2020.
Specimens obtained from ten populations of a species from the central Apennines were compared with six molecular lineages of s. l. (CAN-1, CAN-2, CAN-3, CAN-4, CAN-5, CAN-6) and two other species ( and ), treated as outgroup, by molecular (nucleotide sequences of two mitochondrial COI and 16S rDNA as well as two nuclear ITS2 and H3 gene fragments) and morphological (shell and genital anatomy) analysis. The results strongly suggest that these populations represent a separate species for which two names are available: the older De Stefani, 1879 and the junior Giusti, 1973. The nucleotide sequences created well separated clades on each phylogenetic tree. Genital anatomy included several distinctive features concerning vaginal appendix, penis, penial papilla and flagellum; instead, shell characters only enabled them to be distinguished from and . Remarkably, populations of show high morphological variability. Shell variability mainly concerns size, some populations having very small dimensions. Genital variability shows a more intricate pattern of all anatomical parts, being higher as regards the vagina and vaginal appendix. Despite this morphological variability, the K2P distance range of COI sequences between populations is narrow (0.2-4.5%), if we consider all but three of the 53 sequences obtained. This research confirmed that the species of and their molecularly distinguished lineages can only occasionally be recognised morphologically and that they have significant inter- and intra-population variability. The possibility of using an overall approach, including shell, genital and molecular evidence, was taken in order to establish a reliable taxonomic setting.
对从亚平宁山脉中部一个物种的十个种群采集的样本,与该物种狭义分类群的六个分子谱系(CAN - 1、CAN - 2、CAN - 3、CAN - 4、CAN - 5、CAN - 6)以及另外两个作为外类群的物种,通过分子分析(两个线粒体COI和16S rDNA的核苷酸序列以及两个核ITS2和H3基因片段)和形态分析(壳和生殖器解剖结构)进行了比较。结果有力地表明,这些种群代表一个独立的物种,有两个可用名称:较早的De Stefani,1879年命名的,以及较晚的Giusti,1973年命名的。核苷酸序列在每个系统发育树上形成了明显分开的分支。生殖器解剖结构包括一些关于阴道附属物、阴茎、阴茎乳头和鞭毛的独特特征;相反,壳的特征仅能使它们与另外两个物种区分开来。值得注意的是,该物种的种群表现出高度的形态变异性。壳的变异性主要涉及大小,一些种群尺寸非常小。生殖器变异性在所有解剖部位呈现出更复杂的模式,在阴道和阴道附属物方面更高。尽管存在这种形态变异性,但如果考虑所获得的53个序列中除三个之外的所有序列,种群之间COI序列的K2P距离范围较窄(0.2 - 4.5%)。这项研究证实,该物种及其分子上区分的谱系只能偶尔通过形态学识别,并且它们具有显著的种群间和种群内变异性。为了建立可靠的分类框架,采用了包括壳、生殖器和分子证据在内的综合方法。