J Am Vet Med Assoc. 2020 Dec 1;257(11):1171-1180. doi: 10.2460/javma.2020.257.11.1171.
To assess the readability of pet obesity information, document the presence and absence of types of pet obesity information, and perform comparisons between dog and cat obesity information content on websites.
68 websites containing pet obesity content.
Websites were systematically retrieved with a search engine and predefined search terms and phrases. For each website, pet obesity information was scored by use of 2 established readability tools: the simple measure of gobbledygook (SMOG) index and Flesch-Kincaid (FK) readability test. A directed content analysis was conducted with a codebook that assessed the presence or absence of 103 variables across 5 main topics related to pet obesity on each website.
The mean reading grade levels determined with the SMOG index and FK readability test were 16.61 and 9.07, respectively. Instructions for weight measurement and body condition scoring were found infrequently, as were nonmodifiable risk factors. There was a greater focus on addressing obesity through dietary changes than through increasing physical activity. Few websites recommended regular follow-up appointments with veterinarians. Weight management information and the emphasis on owners' commitment to achieve their pet's weight loss targets differed among dog- and cat-focused websites.
Results indicated that pet obesity information on the studied websites was largely inaccessible to pet owners owing to the associated high reading grade levels. Readers of that information would benefit from clarification of information gaps along with provision of guidance regarding navigating online information and counseling on the importance of nutritional and dietary reassessments for individual pets performed by veterinarians.
评估宠物肥胖相关信息的易读性,记录宠物肥胖信息的类型,比较犬猫肥胖信息在网站中的内容差异。
包含宠物肥胖内容的 68 个网站。
使用搜索引擎和预定义的搜索词和短语系统地检索网站。对每个网站,使用 2 种已建立的可读性工具(简易斯莫格测试和弗莱什-金凯德阅读测试)对宠物肥胖信息进行评分。采用包含 5 个与宠物肥胖相关主题的 103 个变量的编码簿对内容进行定向分析。
简易斯莫格测试和弗莱什-金凯德阅读测试确定的平均阅读水平分别为 16.61 级和 9.07 级。体重测量和身体状况评分的说明很少见,不可改变的危险因素也很少见。更多的重点是通过饮食改变来解决肥胖问题,而不是通过增加身体活动。很少有网站建议定期与兽医预约。体重管理信息和强调主人承诺实现宠物减肥目标在犬类和猫类网站之间存在差异。
结果表明,由于相关的高阅读水平,研究网站上的宠物肥胖信息对宠物主人来说大多难以理解。该信息的读者将受益于澄清信息差距,并提供有关在线信息导航和营养及饮食重新评估的指导,这些评估应由兽医为个别宠物进行。