J Vet Med Educ. 2021 Aug;48(4):492-502. doi: 10.3138/jvme-2019-0160. Epub 2020 Nov 21.
Veterinary schools are facing the challenge of increasing animal welfare (AW) training while also attracting future practitioners to livestock medicine. Both objectives may be better achieved through farm visits early in veterinary training. First year veterinary students at the University of Minnesota (n = 103) were surveyed during the Spring 2019 Professional Development II course to document their knowledge, attitudes, and values relative to pigs, AW, and the industry before and after classroom and online lectures and a visit to a farrow-to-wean farm. Quantitative (Kruskal-Wallis, Kendall tau-c and Chi-Square) and qualitative (content analysis) analyses were used to identify shifts in knowledge and attitudes and associations with demographics and use of the AW values of biological functioning, affective state, and natural living. Most students were female (85.4%), from urban/suburban backgrounds (68.9%), and did not wish to work with livestock (66.0%). Knowledge scores (p <.05) and attitudes toward pigs (p = .0152) improved after visiting the farm. Satisfaction with AW on most commercial farms shifted after the farm visit (p = .0003), with those valuing biological functioning becoming more satisfied (p = .0342). In contrast, students who visited the farm when enrichment was provided were more dissatisfied compared to those who toured the farm without enrichment (p = .0490). Those referencing natural living (p = .0047) rated the toured farm as a poorer steward of welfare. Students' AW concerns included behavioral restriction in individual stalls and injury and lameness in group pens. Farm visits are an important tool in veterinary education, but may result in segmentation in student knowledge and attitudes relative to livestock welfare.
兽医学校面临着增加动物福利(AW)培训的挑战,同时也要吸引未来的从业者从事家畜医学。这两个目标都可以通过在兽医培训早期进行农场访问来更好地实现。明尼苏达大学(University of Minnesota)的一年级兽医学生(n=103)在 2019 年春季职业发展 II 课程中接受了调查,以记录他们在课堂和在线讲座以及参观一个仔猪到断奶农场前后与猪、AW 和行业相关的知识、态度和价值观。使用定量(Kruskal-Wallis、Kendall tau-c 和卡方)和定性(内容分析)分析来识别知识和态度的变化,以及与人口统计学和 AW 价值观(生物功能、情感状态和自然生活)的使用相关的关联。大多数学生为女性(85.4%),来自城市/郊区背景(68.9%),不希望从事与家畜相关的工作(66.0%)。参观农场后,知识得分(p<.05)和对猪的态度(p=.0152)有所提高。大多数商业农场的 AW 满意度在农场参观后发生了变化(p=.0003),那些重视生物功能的人变得更加满意(p=.0342)。相比之下,参观农场时提供了丰富化的学生比没有丰富化的学生更不满意(p=.0490)。那些提到自然生活的学生(p=.0047)认为参观的农场在福利管理方面较差。学生的 AW 关注点包括个体畜栏中的行为限制以及群体畜栏中的伤害和跛行。农场访问是兽医教育的重要工具,但可能导致学生在与家畜福利相关的知识和态度方面出现分化。