Khan Anum, Javed Muhammad Qasim, Bilal Rabia, Gaikwad Rahul N
Dr. Anum Khan, MSc, Clinical Demonstrator, Islamic International Dental College and Hospital, Islamabad, Pakistan.
Dr. Muhammad Qasim Javed, FCPS, Assistant Professor, Department of Conservative Dental Sciences and Endodontics, College of Dentistry, Qassim University, Buraydah, Saudi Arabia.
Pak J Med Sci. 2020 Nov-Dec;36(7):1601-1606. doi: 10.12669/pjms.36.7.2796.
The objective of our audit was to assess the quality of lateral cephalometric radiographs by investigating the percentage of lateral cephalometric radiographic images that satisfied the good quality standards.
The standard-based retrospective audit was conducted at Riphah International University, Pakistan, from April to September 2018. The sample size was 50 radiographs that were randomly selected from the radiographs taken over one year. The radiographs were graded according to the standards set by the National Radiation Protection Board by two evaluators after the necessary calibration. Moreover, the percentages of images that met the criteria set by the Royal College of Surgeons of England were identified. The data analysis was carried out by the SPSS software version 23.
Out of the 50 radiographs, thirty-one were Grade-I, sixteen were Grade-II and three radiographs were Grade-III. Furthermore, out of the criteria set by Royal College, one criterion met the 100% standard that was correct head positioning. Less frequent errors were comprised of poor visibility of soft tissue structures (16%), teeth not properly occluded (14%), Incorrect positioning of labels (12%), Sella and Nasion not visible (8%). According to the results of the quality assurance audit, the radiographs fell short of the required standards.
Quality assurance by periodic auditing is important to yield radiographs with maximum diagnostic value, minimal errors, and avoid unnecessary radiation exposure by repeat radiographs. Recommendations were made for the formulation and implementation of comprehensive radiation protection regulations, at all the Dental institutes of Pakistan.
我们此次审计的目的是通过调查符合高质量标准的头颅侧位X线片的百分比,来评估头颅侧位X线片的质量。
2018年4月至9月在巴基斯坦里法国际大学进行了基于标准的回顾性审计。样本量为50张X线片,这些X线片是从一年来拍摄的X线片中随机选取的。在进行必要的校准后,由两名评估人员根据国家辐射防护委员会制定的标准对这些X线片进行分级。此外,还确定了符合英国皇家外科医学院设定标准的图像百分比。数据分析使用SPSS 23软件进行。
在50张X线片中,31张为I级,16张为II级,3张为III级。此外,在皇家学院设定的标准中,有一项标准达到了100%的标准,即头部定位正确。较少出现的错误包括软组织结构可见性差(16%)、牙齿咬合不当(14%)、标记位置不正确(12%)、蝶鞍和鼻根不可见(8%)。根据质量保证审计的结果,这些X线片未达到要求的标准。
通过定期审计进行质量保证对于获得具有最大诊断价值、最小误差的X线片以及避免因重复拍摄X线片而产生不必要的辐射暴露非常重要。针对巴基斯坦所有牙科机构制定和实施全面的辐射防护法规提出了建议。