Department of Family Medicine, Mie University Graduate School of Medicine, Edobashi 2-174, Tsu city, Mie prefecture, Japan.
Department of Community Medicine, Faculty of Medicine Universitas Indonesia, Jl. Pegangsaan Timur no. 16, Central Jakarta, Indonesia.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2020 Nov 30;20(1):1100. doi: 10.1186/s12913-020-05916-w.
BACKGROUND: Although Japan has a decentralized public health system, local governments have considered expert opinions over those of the community in decisions about public health programs. Differences in communities' interests may create gaps between health program objectives and implementation. We hypothesized that community-based participatory research (CBPR), which involves the community at every step, promotes effective program implementation and community empowerment. This study addressed the first step of CBPR, assessing community needs and developing tailored health program for a rural community in Japan. METHODS: In this sequential exploratory mixed-method study (qualitative followed by quantitative), we first formed a community advisory board (CAB) representing community organizations, city officials, and university researchers. The CAB conducted group discussions with community residents to identify the community's health issues and strengths. These group discussions were analyzed using thematic analysis, and the results were used to develop a questionnaire, which was subsequently sent to all households in the community to obtain priority scores for health issues and proposed action and to assess willingness to participate in community health program. The CAB then designed a program using the overall study results. RESULTS: Ten group discussions with 68 participants identified the following health issues: 1) diseases; 2) unhealthy behaviors; and 3) unsupportive environment. Nature, vacant lots, and local farms were considered local strengths. Of a total of 1470 households in the community, questionnaires were collected from 773 households. Cancer, lifestyle-related diseases, and cerebrovascular diseases were ranked as the most important health problems. Improving services and access to medical checkups, use of public space for exercise, local farming, and collaboration with the community health office were considered necessary to address these health problems. Considering feasibility and the availability of resources in the community, the CAB decided to focus on lifestyle-related diseases and designed activities centered on health awareness, nutrition, and exercise. These activities drew on community's strengths and were adapted to Japanese culture. CONCLUSIONS: The community's priority health problem was closely related to the epidemiology of diseases. The CBPR approach was useful for identifying community's needs and for designing a unique community health program that made use of local strengths.
背景:尽管日本拥有分散的公共卫生系统,但在公共卫生项目决策中,地方政府往往会考虑专家意见而非社区意见。社区利益的差异可能会导致卫生项目目标与实施之间出现差距。我们假设,社区参与式研究(CBPR),即让社区参与到每一个步骤中,会促进有效的项目实施和社区赋权。本研究旨在通过 CBPR 的第一步,评估日本农村社区的需求并为其制定量身定制的卫生项目。
方法:在这项序贯探索性混合方法研究(先进行定性研究,再进行定量研究)中,我们首先组建了一个代表社区组织、市政府官员和大学研究人员的社区咨询委员会(CAB)。CAB 与社区居民进行小组讨论,以确定社区的健康问题和优势。这些小组讨论使用主题分析进行分析,结果用于开发一份问卷,随后将问卷发送给社区内的所有家庭,以获取对健康问题和拟议行动的优先排序,并评估参与社区卫生项目的意愿。CAB 然后根据总体研究结果设计了一个项目。
结果:与 68 名参与者进行的 10 次小组讨论确定了以下健康问题:1)疾病;2)不健康行为;和 3)不支持性环境。自然、空地和当地农场被认为是当地的优势。在社区内的总共 1470 户家庭中,收集了 773 户家庭的问卷。癌症、与生活方式相关的疾病和脑血管疾病被列为最重要的健康问题。改善服务和获得医疗检查、利用公共空间进行锻炼、当地农业和与社区卫生办公室合作被认为是解决这些健康问题所必需的。考虑到社区的可行性和资源可用性,CAB 决定专注于与生活方式相关的疾病,并设计以健康意识、营养和锻炼为中心的活动。这些活动利用了社区的优势,并适应了日本文化。
结论:社区的首要健康问题与疾病的流行病学密切相关。CBPR 方法可用于确定社区的需求,并设计独特的社区卫生项目,该项目利用当地优势。
Rural Remote Health. 2005
Epidemiol Psychiatr Sci. 2023-1-31
Geriatr Gerontol Int. 2015-6
Issues Ment Health Nurs. 2011
Implement Sci. 2011-4-11
Disasters. 2025-4
BMC Public Health. 2025-1-24
J Stroke Cerebrovasc Dis. 2020-3
BMC Health Serv Res. 2018-8-7
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2018-8-3