Looney David, Adjei Tricia, Mandic Danilo P
Department of Electrical and Electronic Engineering, Imperial College London, London SW7 2AZ, UK.
Entropy (Basel). 2018 Jan 24;20(2):82. doi: 10.3390/e20020082.
Approximate and sample entropy (AE and SE) provide robust measures of the deterministic or stochastic content of a time series (regularity), as well as the degree of structural richness (complexity), through operations at multiple data scales. Despite the success of the univariate algorithms, multivariate sample entropy (mSE) algorithms are still in their infancy and have considerable shortcomings. Not only are existing mSE algorithms unable to analyse within- and cross-channel dynamics, they can counter-intuitively interpret increased correlation between variates as decreased regularity. To this end, we first revisit the embedding of multivariate delay vectors (DVs), critical to ensuring physically meaningful and accurate analysis. We next propose a novel mSE algorithm and demonstrate its improved performance over existing work, for synthetic data and for classifying wake and sleep states from real-world physiological data. It is furthermore revealed that, unlike other tools, such as the correlation of phase synchrony, synchronized regularity dynamics are uniquely identified via mSE analysis. In addition, a model for the operation of this novel algorithm in the presence of white Gaussian noise is presented, which, in contrast to the existing algorithms, reveals for the first time that increasing correlation between different variates reduces entropy.
近似熵和样本熵(AE和SE)通过在多个数据尺度上进行运算,为时间序列的确定性或随机性内容(规律性)以及结构丰富程度(复杂性)提供了稳健的度量。尽管单变量算法取得了成功,但多变量样本熵(mSE)算法仍处于起步阶段,且存在相当多的缺点。现有的mSE算法不仅无法分析通道内和通道间的动态变化,还可能会出现与直觉相悖的情况,即将变量之间增加的相关性解释为规律性降低。为此,我们首先重新审视多变量延迟向量(DV)的嵌入,这对于确保有物理意义且准确的分析至关重要。接下来,我们提出一种新颖的mSE算法,并展示其在合成数据以及从真实生理数据中对清醒和睡眠状态进行分类方面,相较于现有工作有改进的性能。此外还发现,与其他工具(如相位同步相关性)不同,同步规律性动态变化可通过mSE分析唯一识别。另外,还给出了在存在白高斯噪声情况下该新颖算法的运行模型,与现有算法相比,该模型首次揭示了不同变量之间增加的相关性会降低熵。