Dzhafarov Ehtibar N, Kujala Janne V
Department of Psychological Sciences, Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN 47907, USA.
Department of Mathematical Information Technology, University of Jyväskylä, FI-40014 Jyväskylä, Finland.
Entropy (Basel). 2018 Apr 12;20(4):278. doi: 10.3390/e20040278.
The Contextuality-by-Default theory is illustrated on contextuality analysis of the idealized double-slit experiment. The experiment is described by a system of contextually labeled binary random variables each of which answers the question: Has the particle hit the detector, having passed through a given slit (left or right) in a given state (open or closed)? This system of random variables is a cyclic system of rank 4, formally the same as the system describing the Einsten-Podolsky-Rosen-Bell paradigm with signaling. Unlike the latter, however, the system describing the double-slit experiment is always noncontextual, i.e., the context-dependence in it is entirely explainable in terms of direct influences of contexts (closed-open arrangements of the slits) upon the marginal distributions of the random variables involved. The analysis presented is entirely within the framework of abstract classical probability theory (with contextually labeled random variables). The only physical constraint used in the analysis is that a particle cannot pass through a closed slit. The noncontextuality of the double-slit system does not generalize to systems describing experiments with more than two slits: in an abstract triple-slit system, almost any set of observable detection probabilities is compatible with both a contextual scenario and a noncontextual scenario of the particle passing though various combinations of open and closed slits (although the issue of physical realizability of these scenarios remains open).
默认情境理论通过对理想化双缝实验的情境分析得以阐释。该实验由一组带有情境标签的二元随机变量系统描述,其中每个变量回答以下问题:粒子在给定状态(打开或关闭)下通过给定狭缝(左或右)后,是否撞击到了探测器?这个随机变量系统是一个秩为4的循环系统,形式上与描述带有信号传递的爱因斯坦 - 波多尔斯基 - 罗森 - 贝尔范式的系统相同。然而,与后者不同的是,描述双缝实验的系统始终是非情境性的,也就是说,其中的情境依赖性完全可以根据情境(狭缝的关闭 - 打开排列)对所涉及随机变量的边缘分布的直接影响来解释。所呈现的分析完全在抽象经典概率论(带有情境标签的随机变量)的框架内。分析中使用的唯一物理约束是粒子不能穿过关闭的狭缝。双缝系统的非情境性并不适用于描述具有两个以上狭缝的实验的系统:在一个抽象的三缝系统中,几乎任何一组可观测的检测概率都与粒子通过打开和关闭狭缝的各种组合的情境场景和非情境场景兼容(尽管这些场景的物理可实现性问题仍然悬而未决)。