Shakerian Sareh, Abadi Leila Hassan
Department of Community Based Education of Health Sciences, Virtual School of Medical Education and Management, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
J Educ Health Promot. 2020 Oct 30;9:274. doi: 10.4103/jehp.jehp_176_20. eCollection 2020.
In Iran, community health workers (CHWs) are native and are only employed in the health-care system. Therefore, the training and empowerment of these staff are essential. The present study was aimed to develop cooperative learning techniques in CHWs to improve both cognitive and noncognitive aspects such as accountability and other social skills in learners.
This study employed a quasi-experimental pre- and post-test design with a control group that was conducted in Kangavar City, Iran, in 2019. Forty-four CHWs were selected using a two-stage cluster sampling, of whom 22 were randomly assigned to the experimental group where the jigsaw technique was applied and the rest to the control group where the lecture method was applied. The aim was to identify job performance and motivation among the CHWs after instruction and compare the two groups. Pre- and posttests were applied to the groups before and after an in-service training course using valid questionnaires. Data analysis was performed on both descriptive and inferential statistics such as mean and standard deviation, paired -test, and covariance analysis with the confidence level of 95%.
The findings showed that the intervention significantly increased the mean score of motivation and performance in the experimental group. Covariance analysis with the removal of the pretest effect was also statistically significant ( = 0.01). Moreover, the MANCOVA test showed the jigsaw technique effect considering motivation and performance with a confidence level of 95%.
Given the well-known effect of cooperative learning techniques and since CHWs have multi roles and tasks, it is necessary to use such techniques so that they can be accountable for developing health indicators in local areas.
在伊朗,社区卫生工作者(CHW)为本地人,且仅受雇于医疗保健系统。因此,对这些工作人员的培训和赋权至关重要。本研究旨在开发社区卫生工作者的合作学习技巧,以改善认知和非认知方面,如学习者的责任感和其他社交技能。
本研究采用准实验前后测设计,并设对照组,于2019年在伊朗康加瓦尔市开展。采用两阶段整群抽样法选取了44名社区卫生工作者,其中22名被随机分配至应用拼图技巧的实验组,其余则分配至采用讲授法的对照组。目的是确定培训后社区卫生工作者的工作表现和积极性,并比较两组情况。在在职培训课程前后,使用有效问卷对两组进行前后测。对均值和标准差、配对t检验以及协方差分析等描述性和推断性统计数据进行了分析,置信水平为95%。
研究结果表明,干预措施显著提高了实验组的积极性和表现的平均得分。去除前测效应后的协方差分析在统计学上也具有显著性(P = 0.01)。此外,多变量协方差分析(MANCOVA)测试表明,拼图技巧在考虑积极性和表现方面具有95%置信水平的效果。
鉴于合作学习技巧的显著效果,且社区卫生工作者具有多种角色和任务,有必要使用此类技巧,以便他们能够为改善当地的健康指标负责。