Bhattacharyya Himashree, Vagha Jayant, Medhi Gajendra Kumar, Pala Star, Chutia Happy, Bora Parash Jyoti, Visi Vizovonuo
Department of Community Medicine, NEIGRIHMS, Shillong, Meghalaya, India.
Department of Paediatrics, Centre of Excellence for Global Collaboration, JNMC, Wardha, Maharashtra, India.
J Educ Health Promot. 2020 Oct 30;9:285. doi: 10.4103/jehp.jehp_406_20. eCollection 2020.
Feedback is an important part of the assessment process. However, one-to-one structured and constructive feedback to the students is not practiced mostly due to lack of practice and feasibility issues. The present study was conducted to understand the perception of students and faculty toward one-to-one structured feedback.
All the 3 MBBS professional students were included in the study. An orientation was given to the faculty regarding the importance of feedback and how to give structured feedback. A standardized format was provided to the faculty for providing the feedback to the students. After completion of the assessments, a one-to-one structured verbal feedback was given to all the students. Thereafter, faculty and student's perception on the feedback process was obtained through questionnaires. A focused group discussion was also conducted among the students.
A total of 42 students participated in the study out of 50. A positive response was received from all the students regarding the feedback. Nearly84.34% of the students acknowledged that feedback is important for understanding their mistakes, 92.84% of the students responded positively that feedback helps to build a good rapport with the teacher, and 92.85% of the students reported that they were satisfied with the overall experience of receiving feedback. Most of the faculty (80%) perceived that giving feedback after the assessment was a good idea. The faculty felt motivated to give feedback to the students after the hands-on experience. However, only 20% of the faculty agreed that the process of feedback was easy to carry out (mean score: 2.2 ± 1.09).
The positive responses received from both the students and the faculty highlight that the students are receptive toward feedback provided it is structured, constructive, and helps them to achieve their learning goals.
反馈是评估过程的重要组成部分。然而,由于缺乏实践和可行性问题,大多未对学生进行一对一的结构化和建设性反馈。本研究旨在了解学生和教师对一对一结构化反馈的看法。
该研究纳入了所有3年制医学学士专业的学生。就反馈的重要性以及如何提供结构化反馈向教师进行了培训。为教师提供了标准化格式以便向学生提供反馈。评估完成后,对所有学生进行了一对一的结构化口头反馈。此后,通过问卷调查获取了教师和学生对反馈过程的看法。还在学生中进行了焦点小组讨论。
50名学生中共有42名参与了该研究。所有学生对反馈都给予了积极回应。近84.34%的学生承认反馈对于理解自己的错误很重要,92.84%的学生积极回应称反馈有助于与教师建立良好的融洽关系,92.85%的学生表示他们对接受反馈的总体体验感到满意。大多数教师(80%)认为在评估后给予反馈是个好主意。在有了实际操作经验后,教师们有动力向学生提供反馈。然而,只有20%的教师同意反馈过程易于实施(平均得分:2.2±1.09)。
学生和教师的积极回应表明,只要反馈是结构化的、建设性的且有助于他们实现学习目标,学生就会接受反馈。