Gupta Kapil, Badyal Dinesh, Mahajan Rajiv, Singla Gesu, Goyal Rahul, Kaur Harsharan, Singla Bharti, Ahi Rajinderjit Singh
Biochemistry, Adesh Institute of Medical Sciences and Research, Bathinda, India.
Department of Pharmacology/Medical Education, CMCL FAIMER Regional Institute, Ludhiana, Punjab, India.
Int J Appl Basic Med Res. 2021 Jan-Mar;11(1):21-26. doi: 10.4103/ijabmr.IJABMR_138_20. Epub 2021 Jan 26.
Feedback is integral in medical education as it improves learner's knowledge, skills, and professional competence, however it is not routinely practiced in medical colleges. Therefore, the present educational research project was designed in a need-based attempt to introduce and implement a program of structured feedback in the department of biochemistry in the first professional MBBS.
The aim was to introduce and implement a program of structured feedback in biochemistry for 1 year medical undergraduates and to collect students' and faculty perceptions about its effectiveness.
it was a prospective, nonrandomized, interventional study.
The study was conducted over 135 first professional undergraduates with six faculties. The feedback questionnaires to assess the perceptions of students and faculty on the feedback program were designed and peer-expert validated. An educational program for giving structured feedback was designed, peer-expert validated, and introduced and perceptions of students and faculty were collected using the feedback questionnaires. The collected data were analyzed in terms of percentages, medians, modes, and satisfaction index and represented in graphs. Transcripts were prepared for qualitative data, themes were identified, and a thematic map was prepared.
Students ( = 135) perceived the feedback sessions to be helpful in making them aware about their learning gaps (70%) and facilitated the process of bridging the learning gaps (62%). Students strongly agreed that feedback has helped in better understanding of the topic (82%), better retention (69%), and acted as effective learning tool (68%). The faculty did not find the feedback sessions as extra burden in their routine schedule (83%). The main themes identified were "More interaction with teacher," "Increased motivation," "Student centric," "Less stressful," "Improved confidence," "Identification and bridging of learning gaps," "Improved efficacy to attempt questions," and "Improved learning."
The feedback program was perceived satisfactory by both students and faculty agreeing upon more of such sessions and implementation in the curriculum in the near future.
反馈在医学教育中不可或缺,因为它能提高学习者的知识、技能和专业能力,但医学院校并未常规开展反馈。因此,当前的教育研究项目旨在根据需求,在医学学士第一专业的生物化学系引入并实施结构化反馈计划。
目的是为医学本科一年级学生在生物化学课程中引入并实施结构化反馈计划,并收集学生和教师对其有效性的看法。
这是一项前瞻性、非随机干预性研究。
该研究针对135名第一专业本科学生和6名教师开展。设计了用于评估学生和教师对反馈计划看法的反馈问卷,并经同行专家验证。设计了一个提供结构化反馈的教育计划,经同行专家验证后引入,并使用反馈问卷收集学生和教师的看法。收集到的数据按百分比、中位数、众数和满意度指数进行分析,并以图表形式呈现。为定性数据准备了文字记录,确定了主题,并绘制了主题图。
135名学生认为反馈课程有助于他们意识到自己的学习差距(70%),并促进了弥补学习差距的过程(62%)。学生们强烈同意反馈有助于更好地理解主题(82%)、更好地记忆(69%),并成为有效的学习工具(68%)。教师们认为反馈课程在他们的日常教学安排中并非额外负担(83%)。确定的主要主题包括“与教师更多互动”“增强动力”“以学生为中心”“压力更小”“信心增强”“识别并弥补学习差距”“提高答题效率”和“学习改进”。
学生和教师都认为反馈计划令人满意,双方都同意在不久的将来在课程中增加此类课程并实施。