Emergency Medicine Unit, LKS Faculty of Medicine, The University of Hong Kong, Pokfulam, Hong Kong, S.A.R., China.
School of Nursing, LKS Faculty of Medicine, The University of Hong Kong, Pokfulam, Hong Kong, S.A.R., China.
J Interprof Care. 2021 Nov-Dec;35(6):890-898. doi: 10.1080/13561820.2020.1831451. Epub 2020 Dec 8.
Effective teamwork is a critical component of maintaining patient safety. However, there is lack of clarity on the best teaching approach to interprofessional teamwork training in medical and nursing curricula. This study aimed to compare the effects of blended classroom plus clinical simulation versus clinical simulation alone on teamwork attitudes, perceptions and performance in medical and nursing students in Hong Kong. This was a pilot study with a mixed-method research design, with both quantitative and qualitative evaluations. Students who studied medicine or nursing courses at a university in Hong Kong were invited to this study. They were assigned into two groups: clinical simulation alone versus blended classroom plus clinical simulation. The primary outcome was attitudinal change related to teamwork behaviours, which was measured using the Human Factors Attitude Survey. The secondary outcomes were perceptions of team-based learning and teamwork performance, which were accessed by the Team-Based Learning Student Assessment Instrument and Ottawa Global Rating Scale, respectively. Four focus group interviews were conducted after the training sessions. Conventional content analysis using inductive coding was performed with the qualitative data. Forty-six students participated in this study. There was a significant increase in the participants' positive attitudes on teamwork for both groups (intervention: = 5.36 and control: = 3.6, <.05); however, there was no significant difference on increasing positive attitudes between the groups (estimate = 1.76, 95% CI [-8.59, 5.06], = .61). Qualitative analysis identified four themes: (1) reconsidering professional roles in managing patients; (2) embodying the experience to share responsibility and complement each other's skills; (3) realizing the importance of trust and communication; and (4) engaging to achieve the mission within a limited time. This pilot study found that a blended classroom did not further improve teamwork attitudes, perceptions and performance in medical and nursing students compared with clinical simulation alone. Qualitative findings showed that students had reconsidered their professional roles in managing patients and realized the importance of teamwork in caring patients.
有效的团队合作是维护患者安全的关键组成部分。然而,在医学和护理课程中,对于跨专业团队合作培训的最佳教学方法尚不清楚。本研究旨在比较混合课堂加临床模拟与单独临床模拟对香港医学生和护生团队合作态度、认知和表现的影响。这是一项具有混合方法研究设计的试点研究,包括定量和定性评估。邀请在香港一所大学学习医学或护理课程的学生参加这项研究。他们被分为两组:单独临床模拟与混合课堂加临床模拟。主要结果是使用人为因素态度量表测量与团队合作行为相关的态度变化。次要结果是通过团队学习学生评估工具和渥太华全球评定量表分别评估基于团队的学习认知和团队合作表现。培训课程结束后进行了四次焦点小组访谈。使用归纳编码的常规内容分析对定性数据进行分析。共有 46 名学生参加了这项研究。两组参与者的团队合作积极态度均显著增加(干预组: = 5.36,对照组: = 3.6, <.05);然而,两组之间增加积极态度没有显著差异(估计值 = 1.76,95%CI[-8.59, 5.06], =.61)。定性分析确定了四个主题:(1)在管理患者方面重新考虑专业角色;(2)体现分担责任和互补技能的经验;(3)认识到信任和沟通的重要性;(4)在有限的时间内参与以实现使命。这项试点研究发现,与单独临床模拟相比,混合课堂并没有进一步提高医学生和护生的团队合作态度、认知和表现。定性研究结果表明,学生重新考虑了他们在管理患者方面的专业角色,并认识到团队合作在照顾患者方面的重要性。