Cardiovascular Research Center and Cardiac Arrhythmia Service (W.G., S.K., A.T.T.L., L.X.H., S.A.L.), Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston.
Stroke. 2021 Jan;52(1):181-189. doi: 10.1161/STROKEAHA.120.030663. Epub 2020 Dec 10.
Oral anticoagulation is generally indicated for cardioembolic strokes, but not for other stroke causes. Consequently, subtype classification of ischemic stroke is important for risk stratification and secondary prevention. Because manual classification of ischemic stroke is time-intensive, we assessed the accuracy of automated algorithms for performing cardioembolic stroke subtyping using an electronic health record (EHR) database.
We adapted TOAST (Trial of ORG 10172 in Acute Stroke Treatment) features associated with cardioembolic stroke for derivation in the EHR. Using administrative codes and echocardiographic reports within Mass General Brigham Biobank (N=13 079), we iteratively developed EHR-based algorithms to define the TOAST cardioembolic stroke features, revising regular expression algorithms until achieving positive predictive value ≥80%. We compared several machine learning-based statistical algorithms for discriminating cardioembolic stroke using the feature algorithms applied to EHR data from 1598 patients with acute ischemic strokes from the Massachusetts General Hospital Ischemic Stroke Registry (2002-2010) with previously adjudicated TOAST and Causative Classification of Stroke subtypes.
Regular expression-based feature extraction algorithms achieved a mean positive predictive value of 95% (range, 88%-100%) across 11 echocardiographic features. Among 1598 patients from the Massachusetts General Hospital Ischemic Stroke Registry, 1068 had any cardioembolic stroke feature within predefined time windows in proximity to the stroke event. Cardioembolic stroke tended to occur at an older age, with more TOAST-based comorbidities, and with atrial fibrillation (82.3%). The best model was a random forest with 92.2% accuracy and area under the receiver operating characteristic curve of 91.1% (95% CI, 87.5%-93.9%). Atrial fibrillation, age, dilated cardiomyopathy, congestive heart failure, patent foramen ovale, mitral annulus calcification, and recent myocardial infarction were the most discriminatory features.
Machine learning-based identification of cardioembolic stroke using EHR data is feasible. Future work is needed to improve the accuracy of automated cardioembolic stroke identification and assess generalizability of electronic phenotyping algorithms across clinical settings.
口服抗凝剂通常适用于心源性栓塞性中风,但不适用于其他中风病因。因此,缺血性中风的亚型分类对于风险分层和二级预防很重要。由于手动分类缺血性中风需要大量时间,我们评估了使用电子健康记录(EHR)数据库的自动算法进行心源性栓塞性中风亚型分类的准确性。
我们改编了 TOAST(急性中风治疗中的 ORG 10172 试验)与心源性栓塞相关的特征,以便在 EHR 中进行推导。使用麻省总医院布里格姆生物银行的行政代码和超声心动图报告(N=13079),我们迭代开发了基于 EHR 的算法来定义 TOAST 心源性栓塞性中风特征,修改正则表达式算法,直到阳性预测值≥80%。我们比较了几种基于机器学习的统计算法,这些算法使用应用于来自麻省总医院缺血性中风登记处(2002-2010 年)的 1598 例急性缺血性中风患者的 EHR 数据的特征算法来区分心源性栓塞性中风,这些患者具有先前确定的 TOAST 和中风亚型的病因分类。
基于正则表达式的特征提取算法在 11 项超声心动图特征中实现了 95%的平均阳性预测值(范围为 88%-100%)。在来自麻省总医院缺血性中风登记处的 1598 例患者中,1068 例在中风事件发生前后的预设时间窗口内存在任何心源性栓塞性中风特征。心源性栓塞性中风往往发生在年龄较大的患者中,伴有更多的基于 TOAST 的合并症和心房颤动(82.3%)。最佳模型是随机森林,准确率为 92.2%,接收器操作特征曲线下面积为 91.1%(95%CI,87.5%-93.9%)。心房颤动、年龄、扩张型心肌病、充血性心力衰竭、卵圆孔未闭、二尖瓣环钙化和近期心肌梗死是最具鉴别力的特征。
使用 EHR 数据基于机器学习的识别心源性栓塞性中风是可行的。未来需要进一步提高自动心源性栓塞性中风识别的准确性,并评估电子表型算法在不同临床环境中的通用性。