Roy-Lachapelle Audrey, Solliec Morgan, Sauvé Sébastien, Gagnon Christian
Aquatic Contaminants Research Division, Environment and Climate Change Canada, 105 McGill, Montréal, Québec, H2Y 2E7, Canada.
NSERC-Industrial Chair on Drinking Water, CGM Department, École Polytechnique de Montréal, Montréal, QC, H3T 1J4, Canada.
Talanta. 2021 Feb 1;223(Pt 2):121802. doi: 10.1016/j.talanta.2020.121802. Epub 2020 Oct 23.
Anabaenopeptins (APs) are bioactive cyanopeptides of emerging concern produced by cyanobacteria. The research for analytical development has recently gained in importance due to their abundance in toxic cyanobacterial blooms. A new commercial enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay kit for the determination of total APs (AP ELISA) has been released promising a rapid response with good cost efficiency for the routine monitoring of uncommon cyanopeptides. The present study explores the suitability of this new kit in comparison with a validated quantitative analytical method based on liquid chromatography coupled to mass spectrometry (LC-MS). The validation results were comparable with both methods for accuracy, precision, and calibration. Method detection limits were more sensitive using LC-MS specifically evaluated at 0.011 and 0.013 μg L for AP-A and B respectively, compared to AP ELISA evaluated at 0.10 μg L for total of the two. For AP ELISA, results were independent from the matrix; however, a systematic signal response was measured in blanks, requiring a blank subtraction in data treatment. Cross-reactivity of AP ELISA was investigated by analyzing ten cyanopeptides selected for their abundance and diversity. Cyanopeptolin A (CP-A), nodularin-R (NOD), microcystin (MC)-RR, [Asp]RR, and HilR showed cross-reactivity with an average overestimation going from 25 to 66%. Considering the contribution of cross-reactive cyanopeptides, thirteen lake samples out of fifteen showed higher concentrations using AP ELISA with overestimation values up to 2261% compared to LC-MS. In light of this study results, LC-MS should still be preconized for the study and monitoring of APs when sensitivity and specificity are needed.
鱼腥藻肽(APs)是蓝藻产生的具有生物活性且日益受到关注的蓝藻肽。由于其在有毒蓝藻水华中大量存在,最近分析方法开发的研究变得愈发重要。一种用于测定总APs的新型商业酶联免疫吸附测定试剂盒(AP ELISA)已发布,有望为罕见蓝藻肽的常规监测提供快速响应且成本效益良好。本研究探讨了该新型试剂盒与基于液相色谱-质谱联用(LC-MS)的经过验证的定量分析方法相比的适用性。两种方法在准确度、精密度和校准方面的验证结果具有可比性。与AP ELISA测定的两种总APs为0.10μg/L相比,使用LC-MS时方法检测限更灵敏,AP-A和B分别具体评估为0.011和0.013μg/L。对于AP ELISA,结果与基质无关;然而,在空白中测量到了系统信号响应,在数据处理中需要减去空白值。通过分析十种因其丰度和多样性而选择的蓝藻肽,研究了AP ELISA的交叉反应性。蓝藻肽A(CP-A)、节球藻毒素-R(NOD)、微囊藻毒素(MC)-RR、[Asp]RR和HilR显示出交叉反应性,平均高估幅度为25%至66%。考虑到交叉反应性蓝藻肽的贡献,15个湖泊样本中有13个使用AP ELISA时显示出更高的浓度,与LC-MS相比高估值高达2261%。鉴于本研究结果,当需要灵敏度和特异性时,LC-MS仍应优先用于APs的研究和监测。