Department of Family Medicine, McMaster University, Hamilton, Canada.
Department of Health Research Methods, Evidence, and Impact, Hamilton, Canada.
BMC Fam Pract. 2020 Dec 12;21(1):267. doi: 10.1186/s12875-020-01339-y.
Individuals living in poverty often visit their primary care physician for health problems resulting from unmet legal needs. Providing legal services for those in need may therefore improve health outcomes. Poverty is a social determinant of health. Impoverished areas tend to have poor health outcomes, with higher rates of mental illness, chronic disease, and comorbidity. This study reports on a medical-legal collaboration delivered in a healthcare setting between health professionals and lawyers as a novel way to approach the inaccessibility of legal services for those in need.
In this observational study, patients aged 18 or older were either approached or referred to complete a screening tool to identify areas of concern. Patients deemed to have a legal problem were offered an appointment at the Legal Health Clinic, where lawyers provided legal advice, referrals, and services for patients of the physicians. Fisher's exact test was used to compare populations. Binary logistic regression was used to determine the factors predicting booking an appointment with the clinic.
Eighty-four percent (n = 648) of the 770 patients screened had unmet legal needs and could benefit from the intervention, with an average of 3.44 (SD = 3.42) legal needs per patient screened. Patients with legal needs had significantly higher odds of attending the Legal Health Clinic if they were an ethnicity that was not white (OR = 2.48; 95% CI 1.14-5.39), did not have Canadian citizenship (OR = 4.40; 95% CI 1.48-13.07), had housing insecurity (OR = 3.33; 95% CI 1.53-7.24), and had difficulty performing their usual activities (OR = 2.83; 95% CI 1.08-7.43). As a result of the clinic consultations, 58.0% (n = 40) were referred to either Legal Aid Ontario or Hamilton Community Legal Clinic, 21.74% (n = 15) were referred to a private lawyer; one case was taken on by the clinic lawyer.
The Legal Health Clinic was found to fulfill unmet legal needs which were abundant in this urban family practice. This has important implications for the future health of patients and clinical practice. Utilizing a Legal Health Clinic could translate into improved health outcomes for patients by helping overcome barriers in accessing legal services and addressing social causes of adverse health outcomes.
生活贫困的人经常因未满足的法律需求而向初级保健医生寻求健康问题的帮助。因此,为有需要的人提供法律服务可能会改善健康结果。贫困是健康的社会决定因素。贫困地区的健康状况往往较差,精神疾病、慢性病和合并症的发病率较高。本研究报告了一种在医疗环境中由卫生专业人员和律师共同提供的医疗法律合作模式,这是一种为有需要的人提供法律服务的新方法。
在这项观察性研究中,年龄在 18 岁或以上的患者要么被主动接触,要么被转介接受筛查工具,以确定关注领域。被认为有法律问题的患者将获得在法律健康诊所就诊的机会,律师将在那里为医生的患者提供法律建议、转介和服务。使用 Fisher 精确检验比较人群。使用二元逻辑回归确定预测预约诊所的因素。
在接受筛查的 770 名患者中,84%(n=648)有未满足的法律需求,可以从干预措施中受益,平均每位筛查患者有 3.44(SD=3.42)个法律需求。如果患者具有以下特征,他们更有可能参加法律健康诊所:种族不是白人(OR=2.48;95%CI 1.14-5.39)、没有加拿大公民身份(OR=4.40;95%CI 1.48-13.07)、住房不安全(OR=3.33;95%CI 1.53-7.24)、难以进行日常活动(OR=2.83;95%CI 1.08-7.43)。由于诊所咨询,58.0%(n=40)被转介到安大略法律援助或汉密尔顿社区法律诊所,21.74%(n=15)被转介给私人律师;诊所律师代理了一个案件。
本研究发现,这家法律健康诊所满足了大量存在于这家城市家庭诊所中的未满足的法律需求。这对患者的未来健康和临床实践具有重要意义。利用法律健康诊所可以通过帮助克服获取法律服务的障碍和解决导致不良健康结果的社会原因,改善患者的健康结果。