Kanerva Mervi, Liikanen Hanna, Pitkäranta Anne
Department of Otorhinolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, Helsinki University Hospital and University of Helsinki, Helsinki, Finland.
Department of Orthopedics and Traumatology, Helsinki University Hospital and University of Helsinki, Helsinki, Finland.
Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol. 2021 Jun;278(6):2081-2091. doi: 10.1007/s00405-020-06476-9. Epub 2020 Dec 15.
To evaluate the long-term (minimum of 2 years from the palsy onset) outcome of pediatric facial palsy by patient questionnaire and face-to-face assessment by the Sunnybrook facial grading system, House-Brackmann grading system, and Facial Nerve Grading System 2.0. To compare the outcome results of self-assessment with the face-to-face assessment. To assess the applicability of the grading scales. To assess the palsy recurrence rate (minimum of a 10-year follow-up).
46 consecutive pediatric facial palsy patients: 38 (83%) answered the questionnaire and 25 (54%) attended a follow-up visit. Chart review of 43 (93%) after a minimum of 10 years for the facial palsy recurrence rate assessment.
Of the 25 patients assessed face-to-face, 68% had totally recovered but 35% of them additionally stated subjective sequelae in a self-assessment questionnaire. Good recovery was experienced by 80% of the patients. In a 10-year follow-up, 14% had experienced palsy recurrence, only one with a known cause. Sunnybrook was easy and logical to use, whereas House-Brackmann and the Facial Nerve Grading System 2.0 were incoherent.
Facial palsy in children does not heal as well as traditionally claimed if meticulously assessed face-to-face. Patients widely suffer from subjective sequelae affecting their quality of life. Palsy recurrence was high, much higher than previously reported even considering the whole lifetime. Of these three grading systems, Sunnybrook was the most applicable.
通过患者问卷以及采用桑尼布鲁克面部分级系统、豪斯-布拉克曼分级系统和面神经分级系统2.0进行面对面评估,来评估小儿面瘫的长期(自面瘫发作起至少2年)预后。比较自我评估与面对面评估的结果。评估分级量表的适用性。评估面瘫复发率(至少10年随访)。
46例连续性小儿面瘫患者:38例(83%)回答了问卷,25例(54%)参加了随访。对43例(93%)患者进行至少10年的病历审查,以评估面瘫复发率。
在25例接受面对面评估的患者中,68%已完全康复,但其中35%在自我评估问卷中额外表示有主观后遗症。80%的患者恢复良好。在10年随访中,14%经历了面瘫复发,只有1例有已知病因。桑尼布鲁克分级系统使用起来简单且合理,而豪斯-布拉克曼分级系统和面神经分级系统2.0则不一致。
如果进行细致的面对面评估,儿童面瘫的恢复情况并不像传统认为的那么好。患者普遍遭受影响其生活质量的主观后遗症。面瘫复发率很高,即使考虑一生,也远高于先前报道的水平。在这三种分级系统中,桑尼布鲁克分级系统最适用。