Department of Political Science, East China Normal University, Shanghai 200062, China.
Shanghai Institute of Global Cities, Shanghai Normal University, Shanghai 201234, China.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2020 Dec 15;17(24):9388. doi: 10.3390/ijerph17249388.
The rapid growth of China's renewable energy market and production capacity has attracted worldwide attention. Environmental policy integration in the energy sector and the institutional background behind this growth have seen little examination. In this paper, we present an assessment of environmental policy integration (EPI), attempting to reveal how the institutional factors facilitate EPI in the energy sector of China. A qualitative analytical framework involving normative, organizational, and procedural dimensions, incorporating multiple pieces of quantitative evidence, was applied. The results show that an ambitious and long-term normative vision covering political will, social backing, and cultural foundation in China is indispensable to the EPI process in the energy sector. The energy agency's trans-sector cooperation in policy-making has been established to overcome the sectoral compartmentalization. China's EPI in energy has a relatively complete and stable regulating system but, at the same time, it is expected to obtain more benefits from market cultivation and public participation. In this process, advantages such as the co-evolution of the green energy innovation, market, and society do exist; however, this market-oriented approach may bring the risk of economic and societal disturbances when interest-driven production capacity growth far surpasses market and societal requirements. This potential risk needs to be handled and prevented by strong governmental guidance and support. The continuous ambitious and long-term visioning of EPI, sufficient governmental funds, and a proactive industrial plan for renewable energy, are suggested.
中国可再生能源市场和产能的快速增长引起了全球关注。能源部门的环境政策一体化及其背后的制度背景鲜少受到关注。本文旨在评估环境政策一体化(EPI),试图揭示制度因素如何促进中国能源部门的 EPI。我们采用了一种涉及规范性、组织性和程序性维度的定性分析框架,并结合了多份定量证据。结果表明,中国在能源部门 EPI 过程中需要具备雄心勃勃且长期的规范性愿景,包括政治意愿、社会支持和文化基础。能源机构在政策制定中的跨部门合作已经建立,以克服部门分割。中国的能源 EPI 具有相对完整和稳定的监管体系,但同时也需要从市场培育和公众参与中获得更多收益。在这个过程中,绿色能源创新、市场和社会的共同发展等优势确实存在;然而,当利益驱动的产能增长远远超过市场和社会需求时,这种以市场为导向的方法可能带来经济和社会动荡的风险。这种潜在风险需要通过强有力的政府引导和支持来加以应对和防范。建议中国不断制定雄心勃勃且长期的 EPI 愿景、提供充足的政府资金,并积极规划可再生能源产业。