Chihara Etsuo, Chihara Tomoyuki
Department of Ophthalmology, Sensho-Kai Eye Institute, Uji, Kyoto, Japan.
Department of Ophthalmology, Shimane University, Izumo, Shimane, Japan.
Clin Ophthalmol. 2020 Dec 10;14:4359-4368. doi: 10.2147/OPTH.S287090. eCollection 2020.
To evaluate the surgical outcome of internal trabeculectomy by Kahook dual blade (KDB) with that of external trabeculotomy, each combined with phaco-lensectomy and intraocular lens implantation (Phaco).
This is a retrospective comparative study. The primary and secondary outcome measures are postsurgical intraocular pressure and postsurgical hyphema. One eye each of 76 primary open angle glaucoma (POAG), pseudoexfoliation glaucoma (PEG) and ocular hypertension (OH) patients underwent external phaco-trabeculotomy, and that of 40 POAG, PEG and OH patients underwent phaco-KDB surgery.
Reduction of the intraocular pressure (IOP) by phaco-KDB at one and two years was 28.4 and 27.8%, respectively, and was not significantly different from that by external phaco-trabeculotomy of 32.7% (=0.256) and 31.5% (=0.468), respectively. Three months postsurgical IOP after phaco-KDB and external phaco-trabeculotomy was 16.1 and 15.9 mmHg, respectively. There was a significant turn back elevation of once reduced IOP to 17.1 (=0.0207) and 17.0 mmHg (=0.0096) at 24 months, respectively. There were no differences in success probability to achieve IOP below 17 mmHg (=0.120), 21 mmHg (=0.719) and >20% IOP reduction (=0.309) with medication(s) at two years between the phaco-KDB and external phaco-trabeculotomy cohorts. Younger age was a significant (<0.001) risk factor for failure; however, presurgical IOP (=0.466), the type of surgery (=0.219) and presence of postsurgical IOP spike (=0.737) were not significant risk factors by the Cox proportional hazard model. Hyphema and spike of the IOP in phaco-KDB and external phaco-trabeculotomy cohorts were 40% and 88% (<0.001), and 53% and 41% (=0.238), respectively.
The IOP reduction by the phaco-KDB was equivalent to that by external phaco-trabeculotomy up to two years. In both cohorts, once reduced postsurgical IOP tend to increase up to 24 months.
评估卡胡克双刃刀(KDB)内路小梁切除术与外路小梁切开术联合白内障超声乳化吸除及人工晶状体植入术(超声乳化术)的手术效果。
这是一项回顾性对照研究。主要和次要观察指标为术后眼压和术后前房积血。76例原发性开角型青光眼(POAG)、假性剥脱性青光眼(PEG)和高眼压症(OH)患者各一只眼接受外路超声乳化小梁切开术,40例POAG、PEG和OH患者各一只眼接受超声乳化-KDB手术。
超声乳化-KDB术后1年和2年眼压(IOP)降低率分别为28.4%和27.8%,与外路超声乳化小梁切开术的32.7%(P = 0.256)和31.5%(P = 0.468)相比,差异无统计学意义。超声乳化-KDB和外路超声乳化小梁切开术后3个月的眼压分别为16.1和15.9 mmHg。在24个月时,曾降低的眼压分别显著回升至17.1(P = 0.0207)和17.0 mmHg(P = 0.0096)。超声乳化-KDB组和外路超声乳化小梁切开术组在两年时使用药物使眼压低于17 mmHg(P = 0.120)、21 mmHg(P = 0.719)以及眼压降低>20%(P = 0.309)的成功概率无差异。年轻是失败的显著(P<0.001)危险因素;然而,根据Cox比例风险模型,术前眼压(P = 0.466)、手术类型(P = 0.219)和术后眼压峰值的出现(P = 0.737)并非显著危险因素。超声乳化-KDB组和外路超声乳化小梁切开术组的前房积血和眼压峰值分别为40%和88%(P<0.001),以及53%和41%(P = 0.238)。
超声乳化-KDB降低眼压的效果在两年内与外路超声乳化小梁切开术相当。在两组中,术后曾降低的眼压在24个月时均有升高趋势。