Department of Geography and Environment, 1916Brandon University, Canada.
Department of Sociology and Criminology, 8664University of Manitoba, Canada.
Dementia (London). 2021 Aug;20(6):2077-2090. doi: 10.1177/1471301220981232. Epub 2020 Dec 18.
In this article, we analyze how mainstream news media frames violence in relation to dementia and the consequences of different frames for people living with dementia and their carers. Conceptually, the goal is to bring literature on citizenship and aggression into dialog with each other. Empirically, a total of 141 regional and national English-language mainstream Canadian news media articles (2008-2019) with a focus on dementia, violence, and aggression were analyzed. Analytically, we examine how different actors are portrayed as victims or perpetrators; how their histories (identities, belonging, and exclusion) are told; how dementia is used to explain events; and what types of expert knowledge and authorities are introduced to make sense of stories of violence in relationships of care. Our analysis points to the implications of media narratives for people with dementia as well as carers and researchers seeking to address stigma and call for change.
在本文中,我们分析了主流新闻媒体如何构建与痴呆症相关的暴力行为框架,以及不同框架对痴呆症患者及其护理人员的影响。从概念上讲,我们的目标是将公民身份和攻击性的文献相互对话。从经验上看,我们分析了总共 141 篇聚焦于痴呆症、暴力和攻击性的加拿大主流英语区域和国家新闻媒体文章(2008-2019 年)。在分析中,我们考察了不同的行为者如何被描绘为受害者或犯罪者;他们的历史(身份、归属和排斥)是如何被讲述的;痴呆症是如何被用来解释事件的;以及引入了哪些类型的专家知识和权威来理解护理关系中的暴力故事。我们的分析指出了媒体叙事对痴呆症患者以及寻求解决污名化和呼吁变革的护理人员和研究人员的影响。