Sist Luisa, Palese Alvisa
Assist Inferm Ric. 2020 Oct-Dec;39(4):188-200. doi: 10.1702/3508.34952.
. Decision Making process and missed nursing care: findings from a scoping review.
Several aspects of the Missed Care (MNC) model have been studied (conceptual aspects, causes, process, measurement instruments, outcomes) however, the decision-making processes influencing the MNC have not yet been settled into an accessible guide.
To describe (a) the terms most used in the literature to define the decision-making processes influencing the MNC, (b) the conceptual models, as well as (c) the available tools.
A scoping review was carried out in March-August 2020 by consulting the following databases: Cochrane Library, Pubmed, Scopus, CINAHL Complete, PsycINFO. Of the 385 retrieved studies, 92 abstracts were evaluated and 36 studies included.
Four terms are used to address the process of nursing intervention delivered on time, postponed or missed: (a) Priority setting; (b) Prioritisation of clinical care; (c) Implicit rationing; and (d) Time scarcity. While the lack of time expresses the common denominator, a substantial difference emerges between priority setting and rationing: the first establishes a preferential sequence of activities with the result of delaying those less significant; the second leads to unfinished nursing care. Decision models to date have not considered the processes influencing MNC; therefore, the available measurement instruments are also of little use.
The decision-making processes underlying MNC have not yet been well understood, and described using different terms. Reliable instruments to measure them are still lacking.
决策过程与护理缺失:范围综述的结果
护理缺失(MNC)模型的几个方面已得到研究(概念方面、原因、过程、测量工具、结果),然而,影响护理缺失的决策过程尚未形成一个易于理解的指南。
描述(a)文献中最常用于定义影响护理缺失的决策过程的术语,(b)概念模型,以及(c)可用工具。
2020年3月至8月进行了一项范围综述,通过查阅以下数据库:考克兰图书馆、PubMed、Scopus、CINAHL Complete、PsycINFO。在检索到的385项研究中,评估了92篇摘要,纳入了36项研究。
有四个术语用于描述按时提供、推迟或错过的护理干预过程:(a)确定优先次序;(b)临床护理的优先级;(c)隐性配给;(d)时间稀缺。虽然时间不足是共同因素,但在确定优先次序和配给之间存在显著差异:前者建立了活动的优先顺序,结果是推迟那些不太重要的活动;后者导致护理未完成。迄今为止的决策模型尚未考虑影响护理缺失的过程;因此,现有的测量工具也用处不大。
护理缺失背后的决策过程尚未得到很好的理解,且用不同术语进行描述。仍然缺乏可靠的测量工具。