Department of Health Services Administration, University of Alabama at Birmingham, Birmingham, Alabama, USA.
Department of Neurology, University of Florida, Gainesville, Florida, USA.
J Am Med Inform Assoc. 2021 Jun 12;28(6):1288-1297. doi: 10.1093/jamia/ocaa289.
Although nurses comprise the largest group of health professionals and electronic health record (EHR) user base, it is unclear how EHR use has affected nurse well-being. This systematic review assesses the multivariable (ie, organizational, nurse, and health information technology [IT]) factors associated with EHR-related nurse well-being and identifies potential improvements recommended by frontline nurses.
We searched MEDLINE, Embase, CINAHL, PsycINFO, ProQuest, and Web of Science for literature reporting on EHR use, nurses, and well-being. A quality appraisal was conducted using a previously developed tool.
Of 4583 articles, 12 met inclusion criteria. Two-thirds of the studies were deemed to have a moderate or low risk of bias. Overall, the studies primarily focused on nurse- and IT-level factors, with 1 study examining organizational characteristics. That study found worse nurse well-being was associated with EHRs compared with paper charts. Studies on nurse-level factors suggest that personal digital literacy is one modifiable factor to improving well-being. Additionally, EHRs with integrated displays were associated with improved well-being. Recommendations for improving EHRs suggested IT-, organization-, and policy-level solutions to address the complex nature of EHR-related nurse well-being.
The overarching finding from this synthesis reveals a critical need for multifaceted interventions that better organize, manage, and display information for clinicians to facilitate decision making. Our study also suggests that nurses have valuable insight into ways to reduce EHR-related burden. Future research is needed to test multicomponent interventions that address these complex factors and use participatory approaches to engage nurses in intervention development.
尽管护士是医疗保健专业人员中最大的群体,也是电子健康记录(EHR)的最大用户群体,但尚不清楚 EHR 的使用如何影响护士的幸福感。本系统评价评估了与 EHR 相关的护士幸福感相关的多变量(即组织、护士和健康信息技术[IT])因素,并确定了一线护士推荐的潜在改进措施。
我们在 MEDLINE、Embase、CINAHL、PsycINFO、ProQuest 和 Web of Science 中搜索了有关 EHR 使用、护士和幸福感的文献。使用先前开发的工具进行了质量评估。
在 4583 篇文章中,有 12 篇符合纳入标准。三分之二的研究被认为存在中度或低度偏倚风险。总体而言,这些研究主要关注护士和 IT 层面的因素,只有 1 项研究考察了组织特征。该研究发现,与纸质图表相比,EHR 与护士幸福感较差相关。关于护士层面因素的研究表明,个人数字素养是改善幸福感的一个可改变因素。此外,具有集成显示功能的 EHR 与改善幸福感相关。改善 EHR 的建议提出了 IT、组织和政策层面的解决方案,以解决与 EHR 相关的护士幸福感的复杂性质。
从这项综合研究中得出的一个主要发现是,迫切需要采取多方面的干预措施,更好地组织、管理和显示信息,以方便临床医生做出决策。我们的研究还表明,护士对减轻与 EHR 相关的负担有宝贵的见解。未来的研究需要测试多组分干预措施,以解决这些复杂因素,并采用参与式方法让护士参与干预措施的开发。