Stearns Rebecca L, Hosokawa Yuri, Adams William M, Belval Luke N, Huggins Robert A, Jardine John F, Katch Rachel K, Davis Robert J, Casa Douglas J
Department of Kinesiology, Korey Stringer Institute, University of Connecticut, Storrs, CT 06269, USA.
Faculty of Sport Sciences, Waseda University, Tokyo 169-8050, Japan.
Medicina (Kaunas). 2020 Dec 21;56(12):720. doi: 10.3390/medicina56120720.
Exertional heat stroke (EHS) survivors may be more susceptible to subsequent EHS; however, the occurrence of survivors with subsequent EHS episodes is limited. Therefore, the purpose of this study was to evaluate the incidence of participants with repeated EHS (EHS-2+) cases in a warm-weather road race across participation years compared to those who experienced 1 EHS (EHS-1). A retrospective observational case series design was utilized. Medical record data from 17-years at the Falmouth Road Race between 2003-2019 were examined for EHS cases. Incidence of EHS-2+ cases per race and average EHS cases per EHS-2+ participant were calculated (mean ± SD) and descriptive factors (rectal temperature (T), finish time (FT), Wet Bulb Globe Temperature (WBGT), age, race year) for each EHS was collected. A total of 333 EHS patients from 174,853 finishers were identified. Sixteen EHS-2+ participants (11 males, 5 females, age = 39 ± 16 year) accounted for 11% of the total EHS cases (n = 37/333). EHS-2+ participants had an average of 2.3 EHS cases per person (range = 2-4) and had an incidence rate of 2.6 EHS per 10 races. EHS-2+ participants finished 93 races following initial EHS, with 72 of the races (77%) completed without EHS incident. Initial EHS T was not statistically different than subsequent EHS initial T (+0.3 ± 0.9 °C, > 0.050). Initial EHS-2+ participant FT was not statistically different than subsequent EHS FT (-4.2 ± 7.0 min, > 0.050). The years between first and second EHS was 3.6 ± 3.5 year (Mode: 1, Range: 1-12). Relative risk ratios revealed that EHS patients were at a significantly elevated risk for subsequent EHS episodes 2 years following their initial EHS (relative risk ratio = 3.32, = 0.050); however, the risk from 3-5 years post initial EHS was not statistically elevated, though the relative risk ratio values remained above 1.26. These results demonstrate that 11% of all EHS cases at the Falmouth Road Race are EHS-2+ cases and that future risk for a second EHS episode at this race is most likely to occur within the first 2 years following the initial EHS incident. After this initial 2-year period, risk for another EHS episode is not significantly elevated. Future research should examine factors to explain individuals who are susceptible to multiple EHS cases, incidence at other races and corresponding prevention strategies both before and after initial EHS.
劳力性热射病(EHS)幸存者可能更容易再次发生EHS;然而,再次发生EHS事件的幸存者数量有限。因此,本研究的目的是评估在一场温暖天气的公路赛中,与经历过1次EHS(EHS-1)的参与者相比,多年参赛的参与者中反复发生EHS(EHS-2+)病例的发生率。采用回顾性观察病例系列设计。对2003年至2019年法尔茅斯公路赛17年的病历数据进行EHS病例检查。计算每场比赛EHS-2+病例的发生率以及每位EHS-2+参与者的平均EHS病例数(均值±标准差),并收集每次EHS的描述性因素(直肠温度(T)、完赛时间(FT)、湿球黑球温度(WBGT)、年龄、比赛年份)。在174,853名完赛者中,共识别出333例EHS患者。16名EHS-2+参与者(11名男性,5名女性,年龄=39±16岁)占EHS病例总数的11%(n=37/333)。EHS-2+参与者每人平均有2.3例EHS病例(范围=2-4),每10场比赛的发生率为2.6例EHS。EHS-2+参与者在首次发生EHS后完成了93场比赛,其中72场比赛(77%)在没有EHS事件的情况下完成。首次EHS时的T与后续EHS首次时的T无统计学差异(+0.3±0.9°C,P>0.050)。首次EHS-2+参与者的FT与后续EHS的FT无统计学差异(-4.2±7.0分钟,P>0.050)。首次和第二次EHS之间的间隔时间为3.6±3.5年(众数:1,范围:1-12)。相对风险比率显示,EHS患者在首次EHS后2年发生后续EHS事件的风险显著升高(相对风险比率=3.32,P=0.050);然而,首次EHS后3至5年的风险虽无统计学升高,但相对风险比率值仍高于1.26。这些结果表明,法尔茅斯公路赛中所有EHS病例的11%为EHS-2+病例,且该比赛中第二次EHS事件的未来风险最有可能在首次EHS事件后的前2年内发生。在这最初的2年之后,再次发生EHS事件的风险没有显著升高。未来的研究应探讨解释易患多例EHS病例个体的因素、其他比赛中的发生率以及首次EHS前后相应的预防策略。