Veterans Integrated Service Network 4 Mental Illness Research, Education, and Clinical Center at the Corporal Michael J. Crescenz VA Medical Center, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA.
Department of Psychiatry, Perelman School of Medicine, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA.
J Trauma Stress. 2021 Apr;34(2):367-374. doi: 10.1002/jts.22642. Epub 2020 Dec 29.
Moral injury, an experience of betrayal or transgression of moral values, continues to receive attention because of its associations with psychiatric disorders, including posttraumatic stress disorder and suicidality. There is growing recognition that moral injury may require novel interventions that involve religious or spiritual paradigms. This pilot study presents feasibility data and exploratory outcomes for 40 veteran participants across seven cohorts who participated in a novel 12-week moral injury group (MIG) over 35 months. The MIG was cofacilitated by a Veterans Affairs chaplain and psychologist and designed to reduce distress and improve functioning in individuals with histories of morally injurious experiences from military service. The intervention included a ceremony in which participants shared testimonies of their moral injury with the general public. Recruitment feasibility and retention were high, with participants completing an average of 9.45 (SD = 2.82) sessions of the 12-week group, and 32 participants (80.0%) attending nine or more sessions and the community healing ceremony. Exploratory analyses revealed medium effect sizes, ω = 0.05-0.08, for reductions in depressive symptoms, improvements in psychological functioning, and self-compassion after the intervention, with small effect sizes, ω = 0.03, in anticipated directions for personal growth and spiritual struggles. The results were not impacted by participant engagement in concurrent psychological treatments. Taken together, these findings support the feasibility of the MIG, the potential merit of an interdisciplinary approach to addressing moral injury, and justification for further research into the efficacy of this approach.
道德伤害是一种道德价值观被背叛或违反的体验,由于其与精神障碍(包括创伤后应激障碍和自杀倾向)的关联,它仍在受到关注。越来越多的人认识到,道德伤害可能需要涉及宗教或精神模式的新干预措施。这项试点研究提供了 35 个月内 7 个队列中 40 名退伍军人参与者的可行性数据和探索性结果,他们参加了一个为期 12 周的新型道德伤害小组(MIG)。MIG 由一名退伍军人事务部牧师和心理学家共同主持,旨在减少有军事服务中道德伤害经历的个体的痛苦并改善其功能。该干预措施包括一个仪式,参与者在该仪式上向公众分享他们的道德伤害经历。招募可行性和保留率很高,参与者平均完成了 12 周小组的 9.45 次(SD=2.82),32 名参与者(80.0%)参加了 9 次或更多次会议和社区愈合仪式。探索性分析显示,干预后抑郁症状减轻、心理功能改善和自我同情的中等效应量(ω=0.05-0.08),个人成长和精神挣扎方面的预期方向的小效应量(ω=0.03)。参与者参与同时进行的心理治疗不会影响结果。综上所述,这些结果支持 MIG 的可行性、采用跨学科方法解决道德伤害的潜在价值,以及进一步研究该方法疗效的理由。