Department of Population, Family, and Reproductive Health, Johns Hopkins University Bloomberg School of Public Health, Baltimore, MD, USA.
Matern Child Health J. 2021 Apr;25(4):528-541. doi: 10.1007/s10995-020-03057-4. Epub 2021 Jan 3.
Warm handoffs intend to improve receipt of services by clients who receive referrals to services that are stigmatized or not easily accessible. Such strategies are characterized as the handoff or transfer of an individual between two service providers through a face-to-face, phone, or technology-assisted interaction. This approach may be useful for maternal and child health home visitors who provide direct services and facilitate connections to community resources for client families. However, little is known about the effectiveness of warm handoffs.
A systematic review of the literature on warm handoffs was conducted with studies identified in four databases. Full text was reviewed for studies for which abstracts met inclusion criteria or for which abstracts were not available. Evidence tables summarizing study characteristics, outcome measures and data sources, intervention descriptions, intervention components, and study results were constructed.
Of the 42,816 unique articles identified, 32,163 titles/abstracts were screened, 227 qualified for full text review, and five comprised the study sample. Three studies examined referrals from substance use treatment centers to self-help groups, one from federally qualified health centers to community mental health clinics, and one from a mobile needle exchange program to substance use treatment/intake. Three studies showed increases in receipt of services by clients following referral between the warm handoff intervention and control group.
Current evidence regarding the effectiveness of warm handoffs is limited. An examination of the effectiveness of warm handoffs in the context of home visits is needed to assess whether they facilitate client referrals.
温馨交接旨在改善接受服务的客户的服务接收情况,这些客户接受的服务是有污名化或不易获得的。此类策略的特点是通过面对面、电话或技术辅助的交互,在两个服务提供者之间交接或转移个人。这种方法对于提供直接服务并为客户家庭提供社区资源联系的母婴健康家访者可能很有用。然而,对于温馨交接的有效性知之甚少。
对文献中的温馨交接进行了系统评价,在四个数据库中确定了研究。对符合摘要纳入标准或摘要不可用的研究进行了全文审查。构建了总结研究特征、结果衡量标准和数据源、干预描述、干预组成部分和研究结果的证据表。
在 42,816 篇独特的文章中,筛选了 32,163 篇标题/摘要,有 227 篇符合全文审查标准,其中 5 篇构成了研究样本。三项研究考察了从药物滥用治疗中心向自助团体的转介,一项从合格的联邦健康中心向社区心理健康诊所的转介,一项从流动针交换计划向药物滥用治疗/接纳的转介。三项研究表明,在温暖交接干预和对照组之间的转介后,客户接受服务的比例有所增加。
目前关于温馨交接有效性的证据有限。需要对家访中温馨交接的有效性进行检查,以评估它们是否有助于客户转介。