Freigang Viola, Butz Katja, Seebauer Caroline Theresa, Karnosky Julia, Lang Siegmund, Alt Volker, Baumann Florian
Department of Trauma, Regensburg University Medical Center, Regensburg, Germany.
Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Regensburg University Medical Center, Regensburg, Germany.
Global Spine J. 2022 Jul;12(6):1208-1213. doi: 10.1177/2192568220979131. Epub 2021 Jan 7.
Retrospective analysis.
The SCIWORA Syndrome (Spinal Cord Injury Without Radiographic Abnormalities) is a rare but potentially severe injury with a peak in childhood and adolescence. With a better understanding of injury patterns and advances in MRI, there is ongoing discussion regarding the "Real SCIWORA" syndrome, a clinical picture of neurologic deficits on clinical examination but absence of radiographic pathologies even on MRI. The purpose of this study was to evaluate mid-term clinical outcome and the psychological impact of the "Real SCIWORA."
In this retrospective analysis, we evaluated 32 patients treated for "Real SCIWORA" between 2007-2019. Inclusion criteria were: neurologic deficit after trauma, no other cerebral or skeletal injury and a lack of pathological findings in spinal MRI. All patients were followed until complete recovery from initial symptoms. 25/32 patients were re-evaluated after 6.9 years (1-14 years) using the Oswestry Disability Index, the Frankel Score, the EQ-5D score, and the Breslau Short Screening Scale for PTSD.
Initial neurologic presentation ranged from Frankel Grade A-D. All patients recovered neurologically during 1-13 days to a Frankel Grade E. The analysis of HR-QoL revealed no difference between the cohort of SCIWORA patients and the German population norm, Oswestry Disability Index showed only minimal disabilities. 4/25 patients showed signs of PTSD.
The "Real SCIWORA" syndrome is a diagnosis per exclusionem requiring a full spinal MRI to ensure exclusion of structural and potentially serious reasons of the neurologic impairment. Further clinical re-evaluation, psychological support seems to be essential.
IV-retrospective study.
回顾性分析。
无放射学异常的脊髓损伤(SCIWORA)综合征是一种罕见但可能严重的损伤,在儿童和青少年时期达到高峰。随着对损伤模式的更好理解以及MRI技术的进步,关于“真正的SCIWORA”综合征的讨论不断,这是一种临床检查时有神经功能缺损表现,但即使在MRI上也无放射学病变的临床情况。本研究的目的是评估“真正的SCIWORA”综合征的中期临床结局和心理影响。
在这项回顾性分析中,我们评估了2007年至2019年间接受治疗的32例“真正的SCIWORA”综合征患者。纳入标准为:创伤后神经功能缺损,无其他脑或骨骼损伤,且脊髓MRI无病理发现。所有患者均随访至初始症状完全恢复。32例患者中的25例在6.9年(1至14年)后使用Oswestry功能障碍指数、Frankel评分、EQ-5D评分和用于创伤后应激障碍的布雷斯劳简短筛查量表进行了重新评估。
初始神经功能表现从Frankel A-D级不等。所有患者在1至13天内神经功能恢复至Frankel E级。健康相关生活质量分析显示,SCIWORA综合征患者队列与德国人群标准之间无差异,Oswestry功能障碍指数仅显示轻微功能障碍。25例患者中有4例表现出创伤后应激障碍的迹象。
“真正的SCIWORA”综合征是一种排除性诊断,需要进行全脊髓MRI检查以确保排除神经损伤的结构性和潜在严重原因。进一步的临床重新评估、心理支持似乎至关重要。
IV级——回顾性研究。