Odor P M, Bampoe S, Lucas D N, Moonesinghe S R, Andrade J, Pandit J J
Centre for Anaesthesia and Peri-operative Medicine, University College London Hospital, London, UK.
Department of Anaesthesia, Northwick Park Hospital, London, UK.
Anaesthesia. 2021 Jun;76(6):759-776. doi: 10.1111/anae.15385. Epub 2021 Jan 12.
General anaesthesia for obstetric surgery has distinct characteristics that may contribute towards a higher risk of accidental awareness during general anaesthesia. The primary aim of this study was to investigate the incidence, experience and psychological implications of unintended conscious awareness during general anaesthesia in obstetric patients. From May 2017 to August 2018, 3115 consenting patients receiving general anaesthesia for obstetric surgery in 72 hospitals in England were recruited to the study. Patients received three repetitions of standardised questioning over 30 days, with responses indicating memories during general anaesthesia that were verified using interviews and record interrogation. A total of 12 patients had certain/probable or possible awareness, an incidence of 1 in 256 (95%CI 149-500) for all obstetric surgery. The incidence was 1 in 212 (95%CI 122-417) for caesarean section surgery. Distressing experiences were reported by seven (58.3%) patients, paralysis by five (41.7%) and paralysis with pain by two (16.7%). Accidental awareness occurred during induction and emergence in nine (75%) of the patients who reported awareness. Factors associated with accidental awareness during general anaesthesia were: high BMI (25-30 kg.m ); low BMI (<18.5 kg.m ); out-of-hours surgery; and use of ketamine or thiopental for induction. Standardised psychological impact scores at 30 days were significantly higher in awareness patients (median (IQR [range]) 15 (2.7-52.0 [2-56]) than in patients without awareness 3 (1-9 [0-64]), p = 0.010. Four patients had a provisional diagnosis of post-traumatic stress disorder. We conclude that direct postoperative questioning reveals high rates of accidental awareness during general anaesthesia for obstetric surgery, which has implications for anaesthetic practice, consent and follow-up.
产科手术的全身麻醉具有独特特征,这可能导致全身麻醉期间意外知晓的风险更高。本研究的主要目的是调查产科患者全身麻醉期间意外清醒意识的发生率、经历及心理影响。2017年5月至2018年8月,英国72家医院中3115例接受产科手术全身麻醉且同意参与研究的患者被纳入。患者在30天内接受三次标准化询问,其回答表明在全身麻醉期间有记忆,通过访谈和记录查询进行核实。共有12例患者有确定/很可能或可能的知晓,所有产科手术的发生率为1/256(95%可信区间149 - 500)。剖宫产手术的发生率为1/212(95%可信区间122 - 417)。7例(58.3%)患者报告有痛苦经历,5例(41.7%)报告有麻痹,2例(16.7%)报告有伴疼痛的麻痹。报告有知晓的患者中,9例(75%)在诱导期和苏醒期发生意外知晓。全身麻醉期间与意外知晓相关的因素有:高体重指数(25 - 30kg·m²);低体重指数(<18.5kg·m²);非工作时间手术;诱导时使用氯胺酮或硫喷妥钠。知晓患者在30天时的标准化心理影响评分显著高于无知晓患者(中位数(四分位间距[范围])15(2.7 - 52.0[2 - 56])比3(1 - 9[0 - 64]),p = 0.010)。4例患者有创伤后应激障碍的初步诊断。我们得出结论,术后直接询问显示产科手术全身麻醉期间意外知晓的发生率很高,这对麻醉实践、知情同意和随访有影响。